1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites
Donald Trump at lectern, smiling
Image: Tom Brenner/Reuters
Politics

Trump bets on law-and-order campaign, again

Stefan Simons Washington
September 23, 2020

The US president has opted for a strategy of polarization in his reelection bid. This time, he attempts to capitalize on the — often violent — protests against police brutality by prioritizing law and order.

https://p.dw.com/p/3itTg

Breonna Taylor was fast asleep in her bedroom when in the middle of the night on March 13, police kicked in the door, barged into the hallway unannounced and raided her apartment, carrying out a "no-knock" warrant in a narcotics investigation.

The warrant had been issued for a different person; police had the wrong address. Breonna Taylor was shot eight times. She was 26 years old when she died.

An investigation into the conduct of the police officers involved in the incident is ongoing, and six officers from the Louisville Metro Police Department in Kentucky are currently under internal investigation. However, until now, no charges have been filed, no arrests have been made.

Taylor's mother filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the city of Louisville and — over six months later — the city's mayor announced that a settlement had been reached. Louisville will pay $12 million (€10.1 million) in damages to Taylor's family.

BLM protesters in Louisville, Kentucky
Initial protests in Louisville, Kentucky were relatively small and peacefulImage: Reuters/B. Woolston

Wave of protests

In the aftermath of Taylor's death, protesters almost immediately took to the streets in Louisville and elsewhere in the country. Earlier this year, most of these protests were relatively small in numbers and mostly peaceful.

Read more: US Attorney General Barr denies systematic racism in police shootings

Police misconduct and aggression and violence against Black Americans had been documented in numerous cases before Breonna Taylor's death. The Black Lives Matter movement formed in 2013 in response to what many consider pervasive structural and systemic racism in the United States — and BLM's efforts have helped make such issues part of the daily national discourse.

For much of the spring, however, national media were paying closer attention to the coronavirus pandemic.

The death of George Floyd

Minneapolis, Minnesota, May 25, changed all of that. A video showing the death of George Floyd in police custody led almost instantly to an explosion of outrage in many cities across the US and in some other parts of the world.

Read more: Protesters take to the streets of France, Germany over police brutality

Protests quickly turned into riots in Minneapolis. As soon as torching and looting of private and public properties and businesses started, the nation and the world took notice — as did President Donald Trump and his campaign managers.

By May 29, President Trump had identified what happened in Minneapolis, and what was beginning to grip the country like a wildfire, as an opportunity to politically position himself as the last man standing against an onslaught of chaos and turmoil. The president started using the protests, violence and rioting as a polarizing tool in his bid for reelection in November.

On Twitter — his favorite means of communicating — he decried a "total lack of leadership" in Minneapolis and promised to "send in the National Guard and get the job done right."

In another tweet on the same day, he threatened that "when the looting starts, the shooting starts."

Trump 'using scare tactics for Americans'

John Hudak, a senior fellow in governance studies and the deputy director of the Center for Effective Public Management at the Brookings Institution in Washington, told DW that the president utilized protests against police brutality and racial inequality for his campaign purposes.

Read more: How people of color experience living in Germany

"He is doing it by using scare tactics for Americans, suggesting that this type of behavior is generated by Democrats and Democratic supporters," Hudak said. "He suggests that his approach to law and order is the stronger one, the more effective one. And that, if Americans fear those types of behavior, they need to stick with his policies."

In just 15 days between Floyd's death at police hands and his funeral on June 9, one fourth of Trump's tweets had focused on unrest, law and order, and the threat of using the military against protesters, according to an analysis by the US daily USA Today.

A return to 2016 tactics

Hudak said Trump's strategy was by no means new. "The president is focusing on a divisive message that pits usually white Americans against other groups," Hudak said. "He did this in 2016, and he is doing it again." 

The difference from 2016 is that, as the Republican Party's presidential candidate, Trump had attempted to stoked the flames of fear by painting a picture of hordes of immigrants about to flood the United States.

"Now he is doing it with regard to individuals in urban areas, particularly black Americans," Hudak said.

Trump attempts to 'stoke the flames of racial bias'

What about Trump's challenger? Presidential candidate Joe Biden and his campaign have strongly denounced the president's divisive rhetoric, but Hudak thinks the Democrats have to do more.

Joe Biden at lectern in Pittsburgh
Joe Biden will have to convince voters that he has an alternative to Trump's law-and-order approachImage: Reuters/A. Freed

"They need to talk about what they will do in the cities, in the communities, the message to Black and Latino voters cannot simply be: This guy is bad, so vote for me," he said.

The nation will see how successful the president's tactics prove to be come November 3.

"The attempt to stoke the flames of racial bias, and flat-out racism, is something that is deeply unnerving in this country," Hudak said. "And, he added, "there is a real social cost to this type of behavior from the president." Many observers across the political fault lines have made similar statements.

For Brian Trascher, a Trump campaign surrogate and member of the Trump Campaign Victory Finance Committee, people like Brookings' John Hudak and others have it entirely wrong.

"The notion that the President is stoking the flames is completely inaccurate," he insists, adding that there is no law-and-order strategy.

"It's the president just making clear where he stands on law and order. He's with the police, he is not for defunding the police, he is not for attacking the police," Trascher explained.

Dividing America has worked for a president before

Some experts have noted that Trump's tone is similar to that of ex-US President Richard Nixon.

Read more: Donald Trump and Richard Nixon: Parallels between Russia and Watergate

In 1968 Nixon ran for president, positioning himself strongly against anti-war-protests and against race riots, which had occurred in cities across the country, winning him the presidency.

John Hudak doubts this strategy will work for President Trump, because "Donald Trump is trying to convince Americans that while these things are happening under his watch and while they should be very afraid of what is happening under his watch, the only solution is to allow him to govern."

A problem with this is that "when this message has been effective in history, it is usually a challenger using this message against an incumbent, because the activities happen under that incumbent," Hudak added.

Armed bystanders at protests

Skip next section Related topics