1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

EU slams Hungary, Poland over democratic standards

September 30, 2020

Budapest and Warsaw remain on collision course with the EU as Brussels airs "serious concern" over judicial independence in the two member states. The criticism has been dismissed by Hungary as "flawed" and "unfounded."

Viktor Orban
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/AFP Pool/J. Thys

The European Union continued its criticism of Hungary and Poland on Wednesday, this time in a report slamming democratic standards in the two countries.

The assessment on the rule of law covered all 27 EU member states and expressed "serious concern" about judicial independence in Hungary and Poland.

"It is relevant to have an overview of these issues, and see the links between them," EU Values Commissioner Vera Jourova said. "Not least because deficiencies often merge into an undrinkable cocktail, even if the individual ingredients seem to be fine."

Read more: Students in Hungary form human chain to support autonomy for universities

The Commission also aired its unease over corruption in Hungary, highlighted by "tight interconnections between politics and certain national businesses."

"The Hungarian citizens need to have the first and last word," Jourova told DW. "It's for them to have a free choice in elections and that we need to make sure that in all the member states, not only in Hungary, there are conditions to guarantee the free and fair elections for the citizens who are the sovereign power in every member state."

Vera Jourova
Jourova told DW that EU money should go to countries "where the rule of law principle is guaranteed"Image: European Union

Budapest and Warsaw have long been at loggerheads with the EU over democratic issues, as well as immigration, with Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban accused of persecuting media that oppose his government while shutting down foreign-owned universities.

Ramping up tensions

The growing discord between Brussels and Budapest increases tensions on the eve of an EU leaders summit. The high-level meeting on Thursday has been arranged to fine-tune a major coronavirus recovery package, but it now looks set to be overshadowed by the rule of law debate.

"The Commission's Rule of Law Report is not only fallacious but absurd," the Hungarian government said in a statement. "The concept and methodology of the Commission's Rule of Law Report are unfit for purpose, its sources are unbalanced and its content is unfounded."

Read more: Protect Poland's LGBT+ community, urge top diplomats

The European Commission's main concerns with regards to Poland relate to its overhaul of the judiciary. This "increased the influence of the executive and legislative powers over the justice system and therefore weakened judicial independence," according to the report.

In Poland, Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki did not refer to the report while presenting his new cabinet on Wednesday, but the country's liberal opposition the Civic Coalition said it indicated criticism of Poland's right-wing government, but not of the country itself.

"It is the current ruling team that is rated so low in the report and its Law and Justice [party] (PiS) that is responsible for all the problems that the European Commission is referring to now," said Civic Coalition lawmaker Kamila Gasiuk-Pichowicz.

Orban calls rejected

The report comes a day after the bloc dismissed Orban's demand for Jourova to resign.

Orban demanded Jourova step down after she lamented Hungary's lack of democracy in an interview with German magazine Der Spiegel.

But the EU's executive arm was quick to reject the request, with spokeswoman Dana Spinant confirming that Commission President Ursula von der Leyen had received Orban's letter but that she has "full trust" in her vice president.

"Our concerns when it comes to the rule of law situation in Hungary are well known," Spinant said, before adding that von der Leyen would be responding to Orban's communication.

jsi/sms (AFP, dpa, AP)

Skip next section Explore more
Skip next section DW's Top Story

DW's Top Story

Former Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy (in lilac tie) is escorted from the House floor after a Tuesday afternoon vote
Skip next section More stories from DW
Go to homepage