EU leaders want large recovery fund, stall on details
April 23, 2020
An EU summit made previously "unthinkable" progress on the economic response to the COVID-19 crisis, according to Italy's PM. But the leaders are still at odds over several details. Follow DW for the latest.
EU leaders agree on need for larger recovery fund, but not on its size, financing, or relation to EU's budget
The US Congress passes a nearly $500 billion spending package to help businesses and hospitals
Tests in New York show that a larger number of people than previously thought might already have developed antibodies to COVID-19
A human trial of a potential coronavirus vaccine has started in the UK, while Germany says similar trials will start by next week
22:48 The US Congress on Thursday passed a $484 billion spending package that expands federal loans to small and medium-sized businesses closed by coronavirus, allowing them to continue paying workers. The package also provides funding for hospitals to expand testing.
22:30 Gilead Sciences dismissed a WHO draft report that stated that its drug remdesivir had failed its first clinical trial to treat the coronavirus. The US company said that the finding of the clinical trial, conducted in China, was inconclusive as the study was terminated early due to low enrolment. The trial was conducted on 237 patients, of which 158 received remdesivir.
“In response to WHO asking for information and studies to be shared early, a draft document was provided by the authors to WHO and inadvertently posted on the website and taken down as soon as the mistake was noticed", said the WHO.
22:20 A New York state survey conducted this week testing for antibodies to SARS-CoV-19 shows preliminary evidence that more people may have been infected with coronavirus in New York than the official number of confirmed cases.
A statewide program testing 3,000 people who were out shopping revealed that nearly 14% had developed coronavirus antibodies. In New York City, which has the highest concentration of COVID-19 cases in the US, more than 21% of 1,300 people tested in the city had antibodies to the virus.
Antibodies are developed by a person's immune system after exposure to a virus, and are a sign that a person has developed immunity. Research on determining how many coronavirus infections turn out to be asymptomatic is ongoing
However, if these numbers indicate the true percentage of infection within the population, it would mean that 2.6 million people in New York state have already been infected, which is a much larger number than the 250,000 confirmed cases.
"If the infection rate is 13.9%, then it changes the theories of what the death rate is if you get infected," New York Governor Andrew Cuomo said Thursday.
Cuomo cautioned that the sample size was small, and said more people would be tested. The results of antibody tests will be important in deciding which parts of the state to reopen, as more data on immunity becomes clear.
21:40 France's health ministry on Thursday said 514 people died of a COVID-19 infection over the past 24-hours. The day-on-day increase of 2.4% was slightly lower than Wednesday's death rate, and much lower than rates from last week that were around 4%. The death toll in France is now at 21,856, and there have been over 120,000 confirmed cases.
21:30 From May 2, care workers from Romania will be able to enter Austria. The Alpine republic is to set up a weekly night train connection to Romania to bring care workers to the country, amid the coronavirus pandemic.
Austria's nursing care system is heavily reliant on Romanian workers, along with workers in other neighboring Eastern European countries, such as Slovakia and the Czech Republic.
21:05 Spain's Ministry of Foreign Affairs has announced the repatriation of 275 tourists stranded in various islands throughout the Philippines due to coronavirus lockdown restrictions, Spanish news agency EFE reported.
According to the ministry, 157 of the tourists are Spanish nationals, 106 are citizens from other EU countries and 12 are non-EU citizens. The tourists are being flow back to Madrid.
Before boarding the plane at Manila's international airport, crew members distributed masks to all passengers.
The Spanish government said 94 Spanish tourists have expressed their willingness to remain in the Southeast Asian archipelago nation for various reasons, while some 1,200 European citizens are still trying to leave the Philippines, according to EFE.
20:45 The Czech Republic is now allowing its citizens to travel abroad for reasons other than work. The country's health minister, Adam Vojtech, said that this decision was taken after conditions improved following the coronavirus outbreak.
"It is possible to travel abroad, even for a holiday. But when one returns, they have to be COVID-negative, with proof by test or go into a two-week quarantine", he said.
19:35 South Africa will start easing its coronavirus lockdown at the end of April, President Cyril Ramaphosa said.
The government will take a "deliberate and cautious approach" during the transition, he added.
The president urged people to wear face masks outdoors and warned that individuals would only be allowed to gather in groups for funerals and for work.
Ramaphosa also said the country's borders would stay closed. Some 58 million South Africans have been in lockdown for five weeks, with the country registering 3,953 coronavirus infections and 75 deaths. Security forces killed several civilians over alleged disobedience of lockdown measures, which include a total ban on alcohol.
19:00 EU member states tasked the EU Commission to "analyze the exact needs and to urgently come up with a proposal" for the recovery fund, which would be of "a sufficient magnitude," said the head of the European Council Charles Michel.
The bloc also signed off on its "Joint Roadmap for Recovery," which calls for an "unprecedented investment effort," Michel said in a statement. This is a more broad mission statement, where financial details are conspicuous by their absence, talking about plans to rebuild the economy once the pandemic eases.
18:28 Italy's Giuseppe Conte hailed "unthinkable" progress following a EU video summit on the bloc's coronavirus response.
"Great progress, unthinkable until a few weeks ago, at the end of the European Council that has just finished," he said in a tweet, pledging to divulge more details in an upcoming press conference.
The Italian prime minister is the main proponent of the so-called "corona bonds" scheme that would allow poorer EU countries to take out cheap loans with the richer ones providing necessary guarantees. However, Germany's Chancellor Angela Merkel already restated her opposition to the idea after the Thursday summit.
18:08 The EU still had to agree on the "exact magnitude" of its recovery fund, as well as its financing and its relation to the next EU budget, said the head of the European Council Charles Michel.
"We welcomed the Joint Roadmap for Recovery which sets out important principles: solidarity, cohesion and convergence. It defines 4 key areas for action: a fully functioning #EUSingleMarket, unprecedented investment effort, acting globally & a functioning system of governance," Michel said on Twitter.
The European Council includes the heads of state and government from each EU member, who in turn choose someone to serve as the body's president.
18:03 Germany will need to pay more into the EU budget after the coronavirus crisis, said Germany's Chancellor Angela Merkel following a video summit with other EU leaders.
The chancellor said all EU leaders agreed that the bloc needed to set up a recovery fund, but noted they were still in disagreement on some points.
"I want to say very clearly that such a joint solution is in Germany's interest, because things can only go well for Germany if they go well for Europe," she said.
The German leader said the European Commission should now design a recovery fund, and that a previously agreed €500 billion aid package should go into effect on June 1st, as planned.
She also restated her opposition to the joint borrowing scheme pushed by Italy.
17:54 The EU's recovery fund will mobilize €1 trillion ($1.08 trillion) of investment, said European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen.
Addressing the public after a video summit of top eurozone leaders, von der Leyen said that EU budget linked with the recovery fund was the best instrument to tackle the crisis.
The former German defense minister also said the recovery needed to follow green and digital principles, and that it was still necessary to find the right balance between grants and loans.
17:48 French President Emmanuel Macron warned there some states still had "very hard positions" on the EU's economic response and that there were more tough negotiations ahead.
Speaking of the need to transfer money to countries like Belgium, Spain, and Italy, Macron warned that the unity of the Eurozone and the common market was at stake.
"If we abandon these regions, if we let part of Europe fall, all of Europe will fall with it," he added.
17:36 Greece has extended its lockdown measures until May 4th, with the government warning that the move "to the new normality will be slow."
Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis would likely announce first steps towards loosening restrictions next week, and the transition should "unfold progressively in May and June." spokesman Stelios Petsas told reporters.
The extension also means that Greece would delay transferring nearly 2,400 migrants from overcrowded island camps to the Greek mainland. The authorities fear that the coronavirus could spread quickly through its camps, originally built for around 8,000 but hosting 42,000 migrants and refugees.
17:25 A study in France suggests that nicotine could help protect people from being infected with the novel coronavirus.
After examining 343 coronavirus patients, and 139 infected people with milder symptoms, researchers found only 5% of them were smokers. This is much lower then the share of smokers in general population, which is at around 35%.
One theory suggests that nicotine adheres to cell receptors and so blocks the virus from entering cells, according to neurobiologist and co-author of the study, Jean-Pierre Changeux.
However, France top health official Jerome Salomon warned: "We must not forget the harmful effects of nicotine."
"Those who do not smoke should absolutely not use nicotine substitutes", which cause side effects and addiction, he warned.
Smoking kills around 75,000 per year in France alone. COVID-19 has so far claimed 21,000 lives.
16:50 New York state governor Andrew Cuomo has taken an online swipe at Republican Senator Mitch McConnell, the most senior lawmaker in the US Senate, over the economic response to the coronavirus crisis.
"One of the really dumb ideas of all time just came from Sen. Mitch McConnell," the Democratic governor wrote on Twitter. "His suggestion to let states go bankrupt makes no sense."
"He says he doesn't want a 'Blue State Bailout.' 15,000 people died — this is not the time for politics," Cuomo said
Previously, McConnell gave interviews to US media where he implied Democrat-ruled states wanted to misuse money from federal coronaviurs relief funds.
"We're not interested in solving their pension problems for them, we're not interested in rescuing them from bad decisions they've made in the past. We're not going to let them take advantage of this pandemic to solve a lot of problems that they created for themselves, and bad decisions they made in the past," McConnell told FOX news.
16:35Irelandreported a massive drop in hospitalization rates on Thursday compared to three weeks ago.
Around 100 new coronavirus patients would be hospitalized every day in early April, but the number has since dropped to around 40, Health Minister Simon Harris said.
He also said that each person infected with COVID-19 was currently thought to be infecting on average between 0.5 and 1 new patients, a drop from between 0.7 and 1 a week ago.
The country of just under five million people has seen 16,671 infections and 769 deaths according to the US-based Johns Hopkins Institute.
16:10 The oldest brother of US Senator Elizabeth Warren died of COVID-19, the politician and the former presidential hopeful said on Thursday.
Warren's brother, Donald Reed Herring, was a retired US Air Force pilot and a Vietnam War veteran. He died some three weeks after testing positive for the new coronavirus, at the age of 86, according to the Boston Globe newspaper.
"He was charming and funny, a natural leader," Warren said on Twitter.
15:38 Russian authorities reported 4,774 new coronavirus infections on Thursday, bringing the total to 62,773. Nearly half the new patients tested positive despite having no "clinical symptoms," health officials said.
The daily jump in infections is smaller than some 5,236 new patients reported on Wednesday and the 5,642 reported on Tuesday.
The authorities also confirmed 42 new deaths on Thursday, including 27 in Moscow. According to the official tally, 555 have died of the virus in Russia so far.
15:25 Developing countries would need to have about $1 trillion (€923 billion) of their debts written off to help them deal with the coronavirus crisis, according to UN agency UNCTAD.
"This is a world where defaults by developing nations on their debt is inevitable," said senior UNCTAD official Richard Kozul-Wright.
One of the missions of UNCTAD, the UN's trade and development body, is to limit countries' exposure to financial volatility and debt.
15:15EU leaders are meeting via video conference to discuss the response to the pandemic, particularly the European Recovery Fund as member states grapple with the economic cost of a pandemic. Countries like Spain and Italy have called for the use of "coronabonds" to help countries that have been the hardest hit, however both Germany and the Netherlands have categorically rejected this proposal.
Ahead of the meeting, German Chancellor Angela Merkel addressed the German Bundestag. She said that Germany and other EU members states were prepared to open their wallets a little wider in the spirit of solidarity, but eschewed any plan, like the bonds, where debt would be shouldered jointly.
European Central Bank Chief Christine Lagarde, who was addressing the video conference, said that a worst-case scenario would see the eurozone lose 15% of its GDP, with a more optimistic forecast being 9%. She warned leaders that they risked doing "too little, too late."
At the start of the conference, European Parliament President David Sassoli said "we are extremely concerned because we can see a downward spiral, and we are going to need every instrument available.'' Making a comparison to World War II economic recovery, Sassoli called on the leaders to come up with a ''Marshall Plan'' for the post-pandemic EU.
14:48 France's schools will start reopening on May 11, but parents would not be obliged to send their children to class, President Emmanuel Macron's office said after he held talks with local mayors.
The youngest students and those who are at the greatest risk from falling behind would be the first to resume their education.
Other students are set to gradually return in the following weeks, although class sizes will be limited to 15 students, according to Education Minister Jean-Michel Blanquer, The limitation could present logistical challenges.
During his talks with French mayors on Thursday, Marcon also said face protection would be "recommended."
Separately, Paris expanded its list of drugs that are not allowed to be exported, ignoring Brussel's calls to lift the restrictions, according to a Reuters report.
14:39 The UK reported another 616 deaths in hospitals across the country, putting the total death in healthcare facilities at 18,738.
The country has recorded more than 138,000 confirmed infections.
The latest daily increase is significantly lower than the 759 deaths reported on Wednesday, when UK Health Secretary Matt Hancock said the nation had "reached the peak" of the outbreak.
14:14Croatia will start relaxing its anti-pandemic lockdown next Monday, Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic said, describing the outbreak as "under control."
The EU country will open most of its stores next week, as well as libraries and museums. Athletes would be also be allowed to train.
However, businesses that operate in close contact with the clients, such as hair or cosmetic salons, will only open on May 4th, according to the prime minister.
In the third and final stage starting on May 11, the country will reopen the some of its schools, restart domestic air traffic, and reopen malls, coffee shops and restaurants, although the hospitality venues could only serve their clients outdoors or on terraces and balconies.
Some measures, such as social distancing, are to stay in place after May 11, and Plenkovic did not specify when all restrictions would be lifted.
Croatia boasts a vast stretch of Adriatic coastline and is a popular tourist destination, with the international lockdown putting it at risk of a huge financial loss.
"We have broadened our guidance on unverified claims that incite people to engage in harmful activity, could lead to the destruction or damage of critical 5G infrastructure, or could lead to widespread panic, social unrest, or large-scale disorder," the Twitter security department said.
5G masts have come under attack in several European countries in recent weeks.
The regulations will also apply to other false and harmful messages relating to the virus, for instance false warnings about food shortages.
12:35Africa has registered a 43% hike in reported infections over the last week, sparking fears it could become the next continent to be severely affected.
The continent home to 1.3 billion people has a "very, very limited" and "very, very strained'' testing capacity, John Nkengasong, director of the Africa Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said. As everywhere, the true number of cases is likely to far outstrip the known tally, Nkengasong said.
The World Health Organization recently released a report warning that the pandemic could result in the deaths of some 300,000 people while pushing 30 million into poverty.
Nkengasong also announced that the Jack Ma Foundation belonging to the Chinese billionaire would be donating 300 ventilators to the continent, prioritizing those countries with none available whatsoever. He alluded to the continent's procurement difficulties with medical equipment in unusually high demand.
"We have to recognize that we as a continent are competing for the same resources that everybody else in the world is competing for," Nkengasong said.
12:00 Italy has begun conducting antibody tests in Lombardy, the country's hardest-hit region in the coronavirus crisis. Health authorities are hoping the antibody testing information will serve as a guide as they try to bring the country out of its long lockdown.
The tests, produced by Italian biotech firm DiaSorin, will look for the presence of antibodies in the blood, or exposure to the virus, and point to some level of immunity.
Health authorities in Lombardy have said that some 20,000 tests will be performed every day. Health workers will be tested first followed by those under quarantine showing coronavirus symptoms and those they have been in contact with as well as people with mild symptoms.
But scientists have questioned the reliability of such tests and have warned that there are still many unknowns as to how the body recovers from a COVID-19 infection.
Recent studies, such as one conducted in March and April by France's Institut Pasteur, have found that so-called "herd immunity" was harder to attain than believed.
Moreover, reports from China, Japan, and Italy of patients who had overcome the virus and then become reinfected, have cast doubt on using "herd immunity" as the rubric to scale back lockdowns.
Some 13,000 people have died of coronavirus in densely populated Lombardy. The figure represents more than half of Italy's total dead.
11:29 UEFA has postponed the Women's European Football Championships to 2022, from its original slot a year earlier, due to a backlog created by the coronavirus.
The tournament was meant to begin in the summer of 2021 but will now start on July 6 the following year after the men's equivalent was pushed back from 2020, overlapping with the women's version of the same event.
It is planned to use the same venues that were originally proposed to host the event in England.
Regarding the rescheduling, UEFA President Aleksander Ceferin said: "When we had to take an urgent decision on the postponement of UEFA EURO 2020, we always had the impact on UEFA Women's EURO 2021 in mind. We have carefully considered all options, with our commitment to the growth of women's football at the forefront of our thinking. By moving UEFA Women's EURO to the following year, we are ensuring that our flagship women's competition will be the only major football tournament of the summer, providing it with the spotlight it deserves."
11:15 Up to half of all coronavirus deaths in Europe have taken place in nursing homes, according to the World Health Organization's (WHO) European office, which called the findings an "unimaginable tragedy."
In a press briefing, WHO Europe Director Dr. Hans Kluge said a "deeply concerning picture" was coming to light regarding the impact of the virus on long-term homes for the elderly, where care has "often been notoriously neglected."
Kluge said the health workers in these institutes, who are often overworked and underpaid, are the "unsung heroes" of the pandemic. He called for them to be given more protective gear and support.
The director said that despite signs of stabilization, the crisis is far from over, and that in the last week case numbers have increased in the east, in Russia, Turkey, and Ukraine in particular. Currently, around half of global infections and deaths are in Europe.
11:00 Taiwan has extended a ban on transit passengers and the limits on direct flights to and from China, in continued efforts to shield the island from the coronavirus pandemic.
Since mid-March, Taiwan has seen a surge of imported cases of COVID-19. As of Thursday, the self-governing island has reported a total of 427 infections and six deaths.
Most foreigners have been barred from entering Taiwan, including from nearby China, Hong Kong and Macau.
But some direct flights connecting Taiwan and the four Chinese cities of Beijing, Shanghai, Chengdu and Xiamen are still being allowed.
However, those permitted to enter the country, including Taiwanese nationals, have been required to adhere to a 14-day home quarantine.
Taiwan's government has not said when the travel restrictions, which were due to expire in late April, will be lifted.
10:50 A cruise ship that became Australia's largest single source of coronavirus infections has set sail from the country's shores one month after authorities ordered it to leave.
The Ruby Princess cruise ship has been linked to 19 deaths in Australia and two in the United States. Australia has seen 75 coronavirus fatalities.
The cruise ship is the subject of a criminal investigation into why 2,700 passengers were allowed to come ashore in Sydney on March 19 before test results had revealed which people had fallen ill with COVID-19.
The Australian state of New South Wales (NSW) has since banned cruise ships from calling at its ports until the federal government can agree on new health protocols.
State police had ordered all foreign cruise ships to leave NSW in late March over fears that sick passengers and crew could overwhelm Sydney hospitals.
The cruise ship's departure was delayed after crew members fell ill, including several whom have since died in Sydney hospitals.
Some 300 Filipino crew members left the ship on Thursday to catch a chartered flight to Manila. Over 500 crew members remain on board.
The ship's operator, Princess Cruises, said the Ruby Princess is now headed for the Philippines.
10:10France's economic activity has been reduced to a bare minimum by the coronavirus pandemic, the country's national statistics office said. Officials are currently weighing the risks of reopening the economy even while the country's infection rate remains high.
"Like a person placed under anesthesia, the French economy can now ensure only its vital functions," the statistics office INSEE said.
The office estimated that activity in the private sector, which accounts for three-fourths of French GDP, has fallen by 41%.
Industries including construction, restaurants, and tourism have come to a virtual standstill since France enacted lockdown orders in mid-March.
Over 10 million employees in the country — one out of every two working in the private sector — have been laid off since the stay-at-home orders took effect. That number is likely to rise, the government said earlier this week.
With economic pressure mounting, France currently hopes to allow all retailers to reopen on May 11.
"Out of fairness, we want all retailers to be able to open on May 11," French Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire told radio broadcaster France Info.
It remains unclear whether this will be possible on a national level, or only on a regional level.
Restaurants, bars, and cafés will remain closed.
09:40 Thai police have arrested numerous individuals over scams involving the sale of face masks.
A 25-year-old man and his 38-year-old step-mother were among those arrested for conning almost 1.5 million baht ($46,000, €42,600) out of a victim who thought she was buying face masks from a police officer. It is not known why she wanted so many masks, a police statement said.
In another case, a 30-year-old woman was detained after advertising masks and other products on Facebook but allegedly did not send the products. The woman had swindled over 200,000 baht from more than 100 people, police said.
Authorities also said there were two other instances involving the sale of overpriced masks. Those found guilty of overpricing goods can face up to five years in prison and a fine of up to 100,000 baht.
Wearing face masks have become the norm in the Asian country since the outbreak as officials have repeatedly urged citizens to wear them.
Thailand has so far reported a total of 2,839 cases and 50 deaths related to COVID-19, according to the government's official figures.
The ultimate goal is to create a vaccine that is both effective and without harmful side-effects, Cichutek told German public broadcaster Bayerischer Rundfunk.
The Paul Ehrlich Institute, an organ of the federal government, gave the green light for the biotech company BioNTech to begin the critical trial on some 200 participants. If successful, larger clinical trials involving thousands or tens of thousands of participants would follow.
Cichutek said the initial results from the first critical trial could arrive within three months.
08:50 Finnish Prime Minister Sanna Marin will work from home for the foreseeable future, her office announced Thursday. The precautionary measure was made after Marin was informed that a close contact working at her official residence tested positive for COVID-9.
"The possibility of exposure is extremely low," an official statement said, adding the Finnish PM was symptomless and feeling fine.
The individual who has contracted the virus was asymptomatic. The person did not meet the prime minister, her family members or her advisory staff when working at the residence, the office said.
08:35 China's Foreign Ministry has suggested that Australia's call for an independent probe into the coronavirus epidemic was nothing more than political maneuvering and said the country should end its ideological bias.
Earlier, Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison had said that all members of the World Health Organization (WHO) should cooperate with an independent review, highlighting China as fundamental in the investigation. However, China has rebuffed the proposal, suggesting it is politically motivated.
Meanwhile, China has pledged an additional $30 million to the WHO to help the global fight against the COVID-19. The announcement comes in the wake of the United States’ decision to suspend its financial contribution to the organization.
08:25 The UK's poor coronavirus testing capacity could further delay efforts to scale back a strict lockdown that has badly hammered its consumption-based economy, Deutsche Bank (DB) warned.
"The UK is lagging behind almost any medium to large economy globally when it comes to coronavirus tests," Deutsche Bank's Oliver Harvey said in a note to clients.
"This will materially impact the government's ability to pursue a 'test-and-trace' approach when it comes to easing the lockdown," Harvey added.
DB's warning comes as British Prime Minister Boris Johnson is recuperating from COVID-19 complications at his country residence. He faces criticism from opposition politicians and some epidemiologists for reacting too slowly to the outbreak.
British Health Secretary Matt Hancock promised 100,000 tests per day by the end of this month, but as of April 21, only 22,814 tests had been carried out. In total, 559,935 people have been tested in the UK.
Britain has 18,100 deaths due to COVID-19 and over 134,600 confirmed cases, according to Johns Hopkins University statistics.
07:30 "Merkel came out as the mother of the nation," said DW's political editor Michaela Küfner, adding that the chancellor told people the government does not have all the answers and that the country will have to live with the social restriction for the foreseeable future.
"[Merkel] spoke like a true world leader and there is a clear recognition here in Germany that as Europe's largest economy it will be footing a significant chunk of the bill of this crisis," Küfner said.
"We’re not living in the end phase of the pandemic," she said. "We’re just at the beginning."
Merkel said making the decision to impose restrictions on public life was one of the hardest of her chancellorship.
"We cannot return to life before the pandemic," she said. "Our everyday lives will be different."
She said Germany had not passed the peak in combatting the virus and Merkel said that even as the speed of the virus' spread slowed, the country was on the "thinnest of thin ice" as the statistics showed developments that occurred 10 days earlier.
While trying not to step on the toes of state leaders, Merkel said she was concerned some of the country's 16 states could be lifting social distancing restrictions too quickly.
"I feel I must admonish everyone not to trust in the principle of hope," she said. "Let us not risk a relapse and losing what we have gained. It would be a terrible shame if our hope punishes us."
Merkel added that it is the government's goal that the health care system not become overwhelmed, as has been seen in other countries. She also said she aimed to make €500 billion in rescue funds available by June.
"The pandemic has shown that it isn't good when all medical equipment comes from abroad," the chancellor said, adding that Germany and the EU would take steps to become more independent in producing personal protective gear.
EU leaders discuss pandemic aid
06:30 The coronavirus pandemic has pushed German consumer morale to a record low, market research institute GfK’s consumer sentiment indicator has revealed.
After registering 2.3 points earlier this month, the indicator fell into negative territory and currently sits at -23.4 points.
"The consumer climate is currently in free fall," Rolf Bürkl, a GfK researcher said in a statement. A value of -23.4 is unprecedented in the history of the consumer climate survey, he said.
"Retailers, manufacturers and service providers must prepare for an imminent, very severe recession," Bürkl said.
Gfk's consumer sentiment indicator is based on a survey of 2,000 German consumers.
The German tendency to save in a crisis has exacerbated the fall, Bürkl said.
A survey tracking consumer income expectations also fell in April to its lowest level since the study began in 1980.
"The fear of job loss has risen sharply among many employees," Bürkl said. "This is a significant barrier to consumption, which is intensified by the fact that closed shops often make it impossible to buy stuff."
06:00 The president of the World Medical Association, a federation of national medical associations, has criticized the decision taken by all German states to require residents to wear face masks in public.
"I wear a mask out of politeness and solidarity, but I think making it a legal requirement is the wrong move," association president Frank Ulrich Montgomery told German daily the Rheinische Post. "People wearing masks think they are safe, and they forget the most important factor, which is keeping a minimum distance from other people."
Montgomery added that wearing the masks improperly could be more dangerous than not wearing them at all. The virus collects in the fabric of the mask, which makes it very easy to become infected when removing it from your face, he explained.
He said only real medical face masks should be required and that requiring the use of scarves or other fabric is "laughable."
At the same time, he said, all "truly effective masks" need to be reserved for use by medical personal.
05:40 Companies in Germany expect restrictions to public life to last for a total of 3.9 months, according to survey figures released Thursday from the country's ifo Institute, a think-tank that tracks the German business climate.
Short-time work is a mechanism in Germany that allows companies hit in an economic downturn to either send their workers home or significantly reduce their hours without having to lay them off with the state paying some of the employees' wages.
"For many companies, short-time work is the method of choice to cushion a lack of sales and to retain their workforce in the short term," director of the ifo survey Klaus Wohlrabe said.
Around 15% of companies have halted production or closed.
Some 84% of survey respondents said they have noted a decline in sales due to the coronavirus crisis, though 45% believe they can make up the loss in the future.
Some 41% of companies in the industrial sector, and 53% in trade, have experienced problems getting essential supplies delivered.
The coronavirus outbreak has caused 76% of German companies to increase their number of employees working from home.
05:10 UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said the coronavirus pandemic is ''a human crisis that is fast becoming a human rights crisis.''
In a video message posted on his Twitter account, Guterres warned about the pandemic's ''disproportionate effects on certain communities, the rise of hate speech, the targeting of vulnerable groups, and the risks of heavy-handed security responses undermining the health response.''
He added that with ''rising ethnonationalism, populism, authoritarianism and a push back against human rights in some countries, the crisis can provide a pretext to adopt repressive measures for purposes unrelated to the pandemic.''
04:50 New coronavirus cases in Germany rose by 2,352, according to the Robert Koch Institute (RKI), Germany's public health institute. The new toll put the total number of infections nationwide at 148,046.
Thursday marked the third consecutive day of rising infections, just as federal states across the country are beginning to loosen up lockdown restrictions. Germany also tallied 215 COVID-19 deaths, for a total of 5,094, RKI said.
RKI figures rely on data from state and local health officials and are updated around once a day, which can lead to deviation from other published statistics, such as those from the Johns Hopkins University.
04:00 European Union leaders will meet by videolink on Thursday for negotiations over an economic aid package to help the bloc's economies recover from the coronavirus pandemic.
Although all of the EU's 27 member states have agreed that a stimulus package potentially amounting to hundreds of billions of euros will be necessary, there are deep divisions over how it should be funded.
Intensions reminiscent of the Eurozone financial crisis, heavily indebted southern states are again depending on relatively financially stable northern countries to do the heavy lifting.
Spain and Italy, which were both severely impacted by COVID-19, are demanding "solidarity" from countries like Germany and the Netherlands, which have rejected the idea of a mutualized EU debt scheme known as "coronabonds."
However, there are low expectations for a breakthrough on Thursday, with one diplomat telling the AFP news agency that leaders are not even expected to issue a joint statement following the meeting.
In an invitation letter, EU Council President Charles Michel urged EU leaders to "work towards" a European Recovery Fund aimed at the long-term rebuilding of the bloc's economy after the pandemic subsides.
The leaders are expected on Thursday to ask the European Commission to provide an estimate of the needs for long-term financial aid. They will also sign off on the 540-billion-euro ($584-billion) emergency aid package agreed to by EU finance ministers earlier in April.
"A different instrument is on the table," Franziska Brantner, a member of the Bundestag for Germany's Green party, told DW when asked about her party's insistence on using so-called "coronabonds" in this current crisis.
"I know that the government and conservative forces have tried to frame it as the same debate as in 2008," said Brantner. But "it is not about us shouldering Italian debt," she stressed, dismissing allegations that coronabonds would essentially be a new version of eurobonds, which led to deep divisions between EU member states during and after the financial crisis a decade ago.
03:50 Two house cats have become the first pets to be diagnosed with the novel coronavirus in the US. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) postulated that the cats had contracted the virus from a human being. The pet cats, who live in New York state, are expected to fully recover.
The CDC urged people to not take action against their pets that could "compromise their welfare." The health institute added that there was still no evidence that pets played a role in spreading the virus.
02:45 Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison said Thursday that all members of the World Health Organization (WHO) should cooperate with an independent review into the spread of coronavirus proposed by the Australian government.
"If you're going to a member of a club like the World Health Organization, there should be responsibilities and obligations attached to that," Morrison told reporters in Canberra.
"We'd like the world to be safer when it comes to viruses ... I would hope that any other nation, be it China or anyone else, would share that objective."
02:30 Daimler AG, one of Germany's biggest automakers, has forecast a 78% drop in earnings before interest and tax (EBIT) to €617 million in the first quarter of 2020. The automaker's Mercedes-Benz Cars and Vans business unit, which makes the iconic Mercedes-Benz branded cars, predicted a more than 55% drop in EBIT. Daimler said that the results were impacted by falling consumer demand owing to the COVID-19 pandemic.
The company said that its total unit sales for 2020 was expected to be lower than that of last year, with a fall expected across all vehicle types – cars, vans, trucks and buses. This is expected to push down the bottom line.
Daimler's dim forecast follows that of BMW AG, another German automaker. The luxury carmaker reported a 21% drop in group sales in the first quarter of 2020, earlier this month.
02:00 The working group of trade and investment of the G20 nations met on Wednesday to discuss actions to mitigate the effect of the coronavirus pandemic on trade, investment and supply chains.
The group also discussed speeding up economic recovery through increased international investment. Meanwhile, Australia, a G20 member, called on member nations to end wet wildlife markets.
"There are risks with wildlife wet markets and they could be as big a risk to our agricultural industries as they can be to public health," said David Littleproud, Australia's minister for agriculture.
00:10 Parties in Germany's governing coalition have agreed on a financial aid package to protect employees and companies from the economic impacts of the coronavirus pandemic.
Due to the coronavirus crisis shutting down vast swaths of employment sectors, short-term unemployment benefits will be extended and increased in stages.
Workers who have had their hours reduced by 50% will receive an increased payment of up to 77% of total net income after the fourth month of receiving benefits. Those still receiving benefits after seven months will receive between 80 and 87%. The current level of compensation is between 60 and 67%.
The German Federal Employment Agency provides short-time unemployment benefits when employers are forced to temporarily shorten workers' hours. The scheme is also designed to prevent people from permanently losing their jobs due to "unavoidable" events.
The aid package also includes tax relief for the hard-hit catering industry and small businesses, with the Value Added Tax lowered to 7%.
The German Federal Institute for Vaccines, the Paul Ehrlich Institute (PEI), gave the green light for Germany's first clinical trials of a potential vaccine against SARS-CoV-2.
The "BNT162b1" vaccine, was developed by Mainz-based pharmaceutical company BioNTech, and the first part of a two-part clinical trial will involve 200 healthy volunteers between the ages of 18 and 55.
The aim is to determine the immune response and whether the vaccine causes any unwanted side effects. The second phase of testing will focus on higher-risk individuals.
The vaccine's developer, Ugur Sahin, said BNT162b1 is a so-called RNA vaccine, which uses genetic material from the virus to stimulate an immune response in the body.
"Trials of vaccine candidates in humans are an important milestone on the road to safe and efficacious vaccines against COVID-19 for the population in Germany and internationally," the PEI said in a statement.
Google has warned that "state-sponsored" hackers are targeting international institutions like the WHO with phishing and malware attacks.
The WHO, and other health bodies directing a worldwide effort to combat COVID-19, have come under sustained digital attacks by those searching for data connected to the pandemic.
Google said it had so far identified 18 million malware and phishing Gmail messages a day connected to COVID-19.
The US state of New York will soon coordinate with neighboring New Jersey and Connecticut on putting together a "tracing army" to find and isolate people infected with COVID-19 and trace the contacts of anyone infected, New York governor Andrew Cuomo says. New York City and the surrounding region are at the epicenter of the outbreak in the US.
In reporting on the coronavirus pandemic, unless otherwise specified, DW uses figures provided by the Johns Hopkins University (JHU) Coronavirus Resource Center in the United States. JHU updates figures in real time, collating data from world health organizations, state and national governments and other public official sources, all of whom have their own systems for compiling information.
Germany's national statistics are compiled by its public health agency, the Robert Koch Institute (RKI). These figures depend on data transmission from state and local levels and are updated around once a day, which can lead to deviation from JHU.