′Too late′ for Hong Kong government to gain citizens′ trust | Asia | An in-depth look at news from across the continent | DW | 11.11.2019

Visit the new DW website

Take a look at the beta version of dw.com. We're not done yet! Your opinion can help us make it better.

  1. Inhalt
  2. Navigation
  3. Weitere Inhalte
  4. Metanavigation
  5. Suche
  6. Choose from 30 Languages


'Too late' for Hong Kong government to gain citizens' trust

Tensions in Hong Kong soared after the death of a student activist and the police's use of live rounds. DW talks to professor Ma Ngok from Hong Kong's Chinese University about the impact in the Chinese-ruled territory.

The death of a student activist in Hong Kong last week and the police's decision to fire live rounds at protesters on Monday has renewed anger among demonstrators.

DW spoke to professor Ma Ngok from Hong Kong's Chinese University about the aftermath of the recent incidents and whether the Hong Kong government can regain citizens' trust.

Read more: Hong Kong: Will violence kill the pro-democracy movement?

DW: Tension in Hong Kong has intensified once again following the death of a college student last Friday and police reportedly firing live rounds at protesters on Monday. How do you think this is going to impact the situation in Hong Kong?

Ma Ngok: The police's action of firing live rounds at protesters shows the recent trend of frontline police adopting more extreme measures against protesters during clashes. Because of the pressure on both sides, I think the situation in Hong Kong is getting more and more dangerous.

I think it's possible for violence to escalate and it could also lead to more widespread protests involving more violent measures. It is obvious that people can easily block streets or metro stations, and while they might start demonstrations peacefully, things can easily escalate into violent clashes with the police.

The important point is that Hong Kong's government seems to have done nothing since last Friday's tragic event, and they instead let the police handle the situation. I think such strategies have been proven ineffective for several months now. It only led to more clashes, further escalation of violence and more casualties. It is the government's responsibility to come out and offer political solutions.

But with the public's deep distrust in the government, how likely is it that what they propose can appease the public's anger?

I'm afraid that it is already too late, but I think people would still like to see some response from the government. It's been several hours since the shooting this morning, but I didn't see the government do anything to address the issue. Clashes between police and protesters continue to take place in different parts of the city.

Based on past experiences, I think the government usually comes out and condemns violence. It definitely didn't help to ease the tension. I think they need to clearly say what they are going to do in order to pacify the situation. They also need to find a way to ensure the public that the police can be controlled. I think a lot of the anger in recent months is aimed towards the fact that the police are out of control and the government is doing nothing to address the problem.

Read more: Sieren's China: Learning from the mistakes in Hong Kong

The police issued a statement to emphasize that individual officers are responsible for their actions and the police department didn't order frontline officers to randomly fire shots at protesters. How should we interpret this response?

I haven't seen the police propose concrete actions to show how they would address complaints from society. No police officer has been punished or investigated for their actions over the last five months, and if the police department thinks some officers have committed mistakes, they really need to do something to address the problem.

Hundreds or even thousands of police officers have committed similar mistakes or crimes over the last five months, and if the police department thinks what the police officer did this morning was wrong, then I think thousands of police officers have committed similar wrongdoings in the last five months.

We are entering the sixth month of protests in Hong Kong and the chaotic situations continue. Do you think this is a new reality for Hong Kong?

I think it depends on the government's position, including both the Hong Kong government and the central government in Beijing. If they believe that they can crack down on all the protests, I think it will further damage Hong Kong's image as an international city. Additionally, it will be very unlikely for them to regain people's trust. If they want to restore real order, I think they need to show that the government and the police force are accountable.

This has been the crux of the issue because people think the government and police can do whatever they want without facing any consequences. This is what makes people angry and if this is not set straight, different forms of protests will continue. While things have calmed down a bit over the last few weeks, what the police have done since last week would likely bring new casualties and further provoke protesters.

The interview was conducted by William Yang.

Watch video 26:06

Joey Siu on Conflict Zone

DW recommends