1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites
A hanging noose
Capital punishment will not be brought back when a moratorium comes to an end, Russian judges decideImage: BilderBox

Russian ruling

November 19, 2009

Russia's constitutional court opts to keep ban on capital punishment in force. Parliament, however, fears a public backlash over a law that would remove possibility of future executions.


A 10-year moratorium on capital punishment in Russia was set to come to an end in January. But members of the country's constitutional court have decided that, due to international agreements, the ban must stay in place.

As a member of the Council of Europe, which guarantees certain human rights, Russia is obliged to abolish the death sentence.

"This decision is final and may not be appealed," said Constitutional Court president Waleri Sorkin, adding that international agreements made any alternative "impossible."

Although the country has signed the European Human Rights Convention, this has yet to be ratified by the Duma, Russia's parliament.

Death penalty has public support

The possibility of a return to capital punishment has fuelled debate in the country during recent weeks. Leading politicians have declared themselves to be against its reintroduction, despite public support for the ultimate sentence.

Violence in the North Caucasus led to demands for terrorists to be executed. One poll showed that only one in four Russians are against capital punishment, with 56 percent in favor.

Members of the Duma are worried that if it ratifies the human rights convention, completely removing execution from Russia's penal code, voters will not be happy.

"We mustn't take up the ratification until we have a public consensus,” said State Duma speaker Boris Gryzlov.

Kremlin wants final ban

The Kremlin has said that it is in favor of a ban. "Society must be ready for the abolition of the death penalty. It's a long process," said Mikhail Krutov, President Dmitry Medvedev's envoy to the Constitutional Court.

Former president Vladimir Putin has called capital punishment "pointless and counterproductive."

Among those executed in 1996, when the death sentence was last carried out, was serial killer Andrei Chikatilo.

Editor: Trinity Hartman

Skip next section Explore more
Skip next section DW's Top Story

DW's Top Story

Belarus President Alexander Lukashenko, turned to his side, and Russian President Vladimir Putin, fully clear, in this picture

Russia to store tactical nuclear arms in Belarus

Skip next section More stories from DW
Go to homepage