1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

Brazil judge who convicted Lula deemed 'biased'

March 24, 2021

Brazil's Supreme Court is set to throw out evidence in the corruption cases against former president Lula, after ruling that the judge spearheading the graft probe was biased against the leftist leader.

Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva clasps his hands together while giving a speech in March 2021
Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva remained a popular figure in Brazil, even when he was in prison.Image: Amanda Perobelli/REUTERS

Ex-president Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva was not treated impartially in the corruption probes of 2017, Brazil's Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday, handing the leftist politician a new victory as seeks a political comeback.

The 3-2 ruling came after Justice Carmen Lucia changed her mind at the last minute, swinging the majority of the five-judge panel in the former president's favor.

The Supreme Court found that judge Sergio Moro was "biased" in convicting the 75-year-old politician, best known simply as Lula.

Moro was accused by Lula and his supporters of conspiring against the popular president, to keep him from running in the 2018 presidential election where Lula was likely to win.

The former judge spearheaded the 2017 anti-corruption investigation known as Operation Car Wash, and later went on to become the justice minister in far-right President Jair Bolsonaro's cabinet.

Earlier this month, a Supreme Court judge annulled the graft conviction against Lula, restoring his right to run for elections.

The Supreme Court is now set to throw out evidence in the cases, derailing the prospect of a swift retrial.

What were the charges against Lula?

A corruption probe known as Operation Car Wash began in March 2014 and soon brought down multiple prominent figures in Brazilian politics and business who were accused of conspiring to embezzle billions of dollars from state oil company Petrobras.

Among them was the former president, who was subsequently convicted of corruption and money laundering.

In 2017, he was convicted for bribery after accepting a seaside apartment from a construction company in exchange for lucrative government contracts.

The following year, another court found him guilty of corruption and he was sentenced to a total of 26 years on charges of taking bribes.

He was released from prison in 2019 after appealing multiple convictions. 

Political revival

Lula is the co-founder of Brazil's leftist Worker's Party (PT) who led the Latin American country through an economic boom from 2003 through 2010, lifting millions out of poverty.

He has remained a popular figure in Brazil even when he was in prison. Lula is likely to pose a major challenge to right-wing President Bolsonaro's reelection in 2022, though neither of them has yet confirmed their candidacy.

Tuesday's ruling further boosted Lula's potential candidacy for the next year's election and vindicated his claim of political persecution.

adi/dj (AFP, Reuters)