1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

Opinion: Lessons for peace in Somalia

Ludger Schadomsky
Ludger Schadomsky
May 12, 2017

The international community has met once again in London to discuss drought-stricken, fragile Somalia. Despite noble motives, the new initiative is likely to fail, writes DW's Ludger Schadomsky.

Großbritannien Somalia-Konferenz
Image: picture-alliance/AP Photo/J. Hill

The list of attendees at the London Somalia Conference was impressive: British Prime Minister Theresa May (pictured above) kicked off the meeting that was meant to serve both as donor and security conference.

UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres, EU foreign affairs chief Federica Mogherini, US Defense Secretary James Mattis and Somalia's new President Mohamed Abdullahi Mohamed, also known by his nick name Farmajo (cheese),  also joined May in London.

The goal of the meeting was to sign off on a "new security partnership for Somalia"; the corner stone of this plan has been on the table since April. That begs the question: What happened to the countless other security partnerships with and for Somalia?

Since the early 1990s, there have been 20 Somalia conferences. The last time the international community came together in London in 2012, there was lots of talk, and promises were made, but the conference did not lead to many concrete results.

Read more: Somalia on the brink of humanitarian crisis

New partnership with new players

That's why a new partnership with new players is needed: Somalia has had a new president, premier and parliament since the beginning of this year. The country is also battling a fresh hunger crisis. The UN and aid organizations therefore agreed to increase their appeal for aid to $1.5 billion (1.4 billion euros) for the country in the Horn of Africa region that has been plagued by hunger and drought.

Over the course of 17 pages, the attendees laid out the key goal for future cooperation through 2020: the speedy creation of a powerful Somalian army made up of scattered regional troops and clan militia.

Somalia Hunger und Cholera fordern  mindestens 110 Todesopfer
Somali girls stand in line to receive food aidImage: picture alliance/AP Photo/F. Abdi Warsameh

Time is of the essence: By 2018, the 22,000-strong but largely ineffective African Union-led AMISOM troops are set to be reduced before one day being replaced entirerly by Somali forces. The donors are willing to dig deep into their pockets to fund these troops and their training, among other things.

Lessons learned?

However, more money doesn't translate to greater achievement in Somalia - that's the lesson learned from a quarter century of thoroughly botched intervention.

On the contrary: Corruption, nepotism and politicians' tendency to freely fill their own pockets are endemic in the country today. These practices are much more common than an interest in reform and good governance.

The so-called roadmap that has been discussed for years is still at a standstill as the president and prime minister, as well as the regions within the fragile federal state, are blocking each other from implementing it. Clan allegiance still trumps a national sense of belonging.

Ludger Schadomsky(photo: DW)
Ludger Schadomsky is the head of DW's Amharic serviceImage: DW

Many Somalis who returned from abroad full of hope after the last election in 2012 are now frustrated and disillusioned.

President Mohamed's statement that he plans to defeat the Islamist al-Shabab militia, whose fighters have been terrorizing Somalia's capital Mogadishu by unleashing attacks similar to those in Kabul and Baghdad, within the next two years is as if to add insult to injury.

Somalia's new president used to work as a financial administrator in the US for four years and wrote a thesis on "US strategic interests in Somalia: From Cold War era to War on Terror." Both these topics - finance and the fight against terrorism - are essential for Somalia's future, so the new president does bring new hope to the office.

But the to-do list is long: rebuilding the country's police and military forces, reforming the constitution, national dialogue, fighting corruption and the recent uptick in pirate activites, to name a few. German Foreign Minister Sigmar Gabriel is right when he warns there's only a brief time frame for establishing a Somali army.

Außenminister Gabriel besucht Somalia
Somalia's Prime Minister Khaire greets German Foreign Minister Gabriel on the latter's recent visit to SomaliaImage: picture alliance/dpa/M.Gambarini

Despite the many domestic failures in Somalia, the truth is the donor community has not covered itself in glory in the past either. If they mean business with that "new deal" for Somalia, it's time to do it right this time.

London too busy with Brexit

But realpolitik might get in the way: The UK, the patron of international Somalia diplomacy, will be busy dealing with Brexit in the coming years and might only be willing to bother with captured British crude oil vessels close to Somalia's shores.

But this message didn't find its way into the 17 pages "tough lady" May gave to the Somali guests as a parting gift.

Have something to say? Please leave your comment under this article! The thread automatically closes after 24 hours.

Skip next section Explore more
Skip next section Related topics
Skip next section DW's Top Story

DW's Top Story

Site of a damaged apartment building in Kharkiv, Ukraine

Ukraine updates: Zelenskyy urges faster weapon deliveries

Skip next section More stories from DW
Go to homepage