1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

Activists shut down key Canada-US oil pipelines

Melanie Hall
October 12, 2016

Activists disrupted the flow of millions of barrels of crude oil from Canada to the US by turning off valves on North America's pipeline system. An action of this magnitude by environmentalists is thought unprecedented.

08.04.2014 DW Global 3000 Kanada Pipeline
Image: DW

Protesters carried out the audacious act of sabotage by simultaneously twisting shut giant valves on five cross-border pipes that together can carry up to 2.8 million barrels of crude oil a day - around 15 percent of daily US consumption.

After months of studying how to shut the pipes safely, climate activists in four states cut padlocks and chains to enter the remote flow stations in coordinated early-morning raids on Tuesday.

Before the latest sabotage, environmental activists are not thought to have ever previously carried out a simultaneous, coordinated action of this magnitude.

Police confirmed four arrests: three in Washington state and one in Montana, while protesters were also arrested in Minnesota and North Dakota.

USA Sioux in North Dakota Protest against the pipeline
Protesters have taken direct action to halt work on the Dakota Access oil pipelineImage: Reuters/A. Cullen

The group said the move was in support of opponents of the disputed Dakota Access Pipeline, a proposed separate $3.7 billion pipeline carrying oil from North Dakota to the US Gulf Coast.

Critics say the Dakota Access Pipeline could rupture, fouling drinking water for the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe in North Dakota. Environmental activists, particularly climate activists calling for an end to development of fossil fuels, have joined their ranks.

On Monday, 27 people were arrested for protesting the Dakota Access pipeline, including actress Shailene Woodley.

‘Dangerous stunt’

Members from a group calling itself Climate Direct Action caused no damage to the pipelines - but officials, experts and pipeline companies said the protesters risked serious environmental damage by shutting down the lines.

They said unscheduled shutdowns can lead to a buildup of pressure, which can cause leaks or ruptures.

Carl Weimer, executive director at the industry watchdog Pipeline Safety Trust, said the action was a "dangerous stunt."

"Closing valves on major pipelines can have unexpected consequences, endangering people and the environment," he said.

USA Keystone XL Pipeline Öl Kanada
The Keystone oil pipeline has become a symbol of the battle over climate change and fossil fuelsImage: REUTERS/TransCanada Corporation

Pipelines can be heavily pressurized depending on length and altitude variation. Paul Tullis of Tullis Engineering Consultants said oil moves with momentum "like a freight train."

"If these people are hydraulic engineers, they might be able to do this safely," he said, adding that activists often do not fully know what they are doing - even if they think they do.

Afrin Sopariwala, a spokeswoman for Climate Direct Action, pointed to the cause as justification: "We are acting in response to this catastrophe we are facing," referring to global warming.

Environmentalists have fought for years to stem production of oil from Canadian tar sands, which is being transported in these pipelines, in favor of cleaner energy.

The shutdown had little impact on the oil market, and the lines were soon restarted.

Pipelines targeted

The incident is the most recent in a series of actions by environmentalists and others in response to growing concern over the effects of fossil fuels on the environment.

Protesters have previously shut down lines in more isolated incidents - but this has been rare, said Richard Kuprewicz, president of pipeline safety consultancy Accufacts Inc.

"It's rare because ... you can be prosecuted and go to jail," he said. "Even if nothing happens, it can be dealt with very harshly."

For an industry increasingly reliant on technology such as infrared cameras, digital sensors and drones - to monitor security and check for leaks - the sabotage illustrates how vulnerable pipelines are to low-tech attacks.