1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

Bolsonaro's indigenous stance 'discriminatory, racist'

Karina Gomes
January 4, 2019

Brazil's new president, Jair Bolsonaro, has wasted little time in targeting the country's indigenous people. UN rapporteur Victoria Tauli-Corpuz told DW that a move to expand farming will put indigenous rights at risk.

A group of indigenous people protesting in Brazil
Image: Getty Images/AFP/C. De Souza

DW: Jair Bolsonaro has issued an executive order making the Agriculture Ministry responsible for deciding what to do with lands claimed by indigenous peoples, stripping power from the indigenous affairs agency, FUNAI. How do you see these developments?

Victoria Tauli-Corpuz: This is a regressive move, because the Agriculture Ministry is the agency which supports the expansion of the areas for the production of crops for export and for cattle ranching. Putting FUNAI under a body which has the function of facilitating the expansion of agriculture, including to the indigenous peoples' lands and territories, will potentially undermine FUNAI's mandate which is to protect the rights of indigenous peoples to their lands and territories.

UN special rapporteur on indigenous peoples, Victoria Tauli-Corpuz
'Entering [indigenous] territories ... can lead to the disappearance or genocide of these peoples': Tauli-CorpuzImage: Getty Images/AFP/O. Estrada

What can possibly happen is that FUNAI's mandate will be changed or its resources and powers will be reduced significantly which will make it very weak in terms of performing its role of protecting the rights of indigenous peoples.

Read moreBrazil: Experts warn of Bolsonaro threat to the Amazon

What is the impact of such a measure on the future of the Amazon rainforest?

Since the Amazon rainforest will be among the potential areas for agricultural expansion, this will mean increased deforestation and increased displacements and violations of the rights of indigenous peoples in the Amazon. It will also mean that the capacity of the rainforest for climate change mitigation will decrease.

On Twitter, Bolsonaro emphasized the need to integrate indigenous peoples in Brazilian society, pointing out that they live in isolated territories rich in natural resources that need to serve economic purposes. What do you make of that statement?

Brazilian dam threatens indigenous way of life

This is a discriminatory and racist statement which is not in compliance with Brazil's legal obligations to international human rights laws and standards. The ILO [International Labor Organization] Convention No. 169, which Brazil ratified, and the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples strongly affirm that indigenous peoples have the right to determine whether they would like to be integrated into the dominant society or maintain their own cultures and identities.

Brazil also has approved the guidelines for indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation, from the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, which stipulates that they have the right to remain in isolation and not be contacted. Entering the territories where indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation are living can lead to the disappearance or genocide of these peoples.

Read more: Opinion: Brazil's Bolsonaro sworn in but still campaigning

During his presidential campaign, Bolsonaro promised he would no longer give one inch of land to indigenous peoples. How do you assess this increasing deterioration of their rights?

Again, such pronouncements violate the rights of indigenous peoples, and I certainly hope the president will not do this.

Your study, "Cornered by Protected Areas", shows that indigenous peoples and local communities play a crucial role in the protection of the world's forests and biodiversity. How important is the legal demarcation of indigenous lands?

The research that has been done in the past few years shows that when indigenous peoples' lands are demarcated and their rights to these lands are respected, the integrity of the forests and the biodiversity are kept in a much better state. Demarcating lands of indigenous peoples which include forests is one of the most effective ways of saving the last remaining forest and biodiversity on the planet. Respecting and protecting the land, territorial and resource rights of indigenous peoples, therefore, is directly linked to achieving the goals of the biodiversity and climate change conventions.

Victoria Tauli-Corpuz is the UN's special rapporteur on the rights of indigenous peoples.

Brazil's indigenous population fights back