Take a look at the beta version of dw.com. We're not done yet! Your opinion can help us make it better.
A mysterious PR agency offered health bloggers money for spreading false information on the risks posed by the BioNTech-Pfizer COVID vaccine. It can be traced back to Russia.
"C'est étrange" (This is strange) — that's how YouTuber Leo Grasset started his Twitter message on May 24. Grasset runs the popular science channel DirtyBiology and in his tweet, he recounted how he was contacted by a PR agency called "Fazze," which offered him a considerable amount of money to falsely discredit the BioNTech-Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine.
According to Grasset, there were preconditions: He had to phrase it in a way as to make it clear he was expressing his own opinion, and not acting at the behest of the PR agency. "Say that you're interested in the different vaccines and that you had discovered some information which the mainstream media were deliberately not reporting on," Fazze requested.
Grasset declined the offer.
In an interview with French public broadcasterFrance 5, Grasset said he was aware that surreptitious advertising is illegal in France. But his main concern was to avoid the spread of false information. The agency had asked him to say there was a high fatality risk in connection with the BioNTech-Pfizer vaccine. As "proof," he was given a list of undocumented origin purportedly showing that the death rate among people who had received the BioNTech jab was significantly higher than for those who had AstraZeneca or Johnson & Johnson.
Grasset was one of several influencers who were approached by Fazze across France and Germany.
Mirko Drotschmann, who runs a German-language science channel on YouTube under the name of MrWissen2Go with 1.5 million followers, says he was approached in the same way.
"I was surprised and taken aback, at the idea that the people in this agency would assume that I'd go for this kind of deal," Drotschmann told DW. "They obviously didn't know me at all," he said, still amazed at the company's "very crude" tactics.
The BioNTech-Pfizer vaccine is being used extensively across Europe, and in early May, the EU ordered an additional 1.8 billion doses. Since then, there has been an increasing number of reports attempting to discredit the vaccine, many of which can be traced back to Moscow or Beijing. The EU warned in April that there was a rising number of spurious reports falsely claiming that European and US vaccines were linked to a number of deaths across Europe, while praising the safety and superiority of Russian and Chinese vaccines.
The PR agency Fazze has come under scrutiny from French media, which found that the company's London address was fake. French daily Le Monde, Numerama online news, and others found that Fazze is not registered in the UK at all, and traces appear to lead to a mailbox in the Virgin Islands.
Le Monde was able to trace back the email communication with the French influencers and found they had been sent from the account of a supposed Head of Sales, who was based in Moscow, not London.
Meanwhile, the fazze.com website has been taken offline, all employee accounts are no longer accessible, and all links posted on Reddit straight after Grasset's revelations have been deleted.
In its communication with the science bloggers, Fazze never mentioned the Russian vaccine Sputnik V. But political scientist and Russia expert Janis Kluge, with the German Institute for International and Security Affairs (SWP), believes that links to Russia are plausible. The table that is supposed to be published by influencers resembles the rhetoric of the Sputnik V Twitter account, says Kluge. On Twitter, Sputnik V has recently published similar numbers, seeming to indicate that the number of deaths in connection with Western vaccines was higher.
"Russian business interests are the motivation for these fake news campaigns," said Kluge. "It is about improving Russia's image as a world power with high-tech expertise. And throwing dirt on competitors is part of the game," he said.
It is unknown how many science bloggers may have accepted the offer from the Fazze PR agency. But Grasset says he hopes those who did accept had no time to spread the fake news before the scam was made public.
This article was corrected on May 29, 2021. The English translation did not correspond to the original version of the article published in German.
This article has been translated from German.