1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

Macron fires aide filmed beating protester

July 20, 2018

French President Emmanuel Macron has fired his security aide Alexandre Benalla for beating a protester and impersonating a police officer. Macron faces fierce criticism for failing to respond to the incident sooner.

Frankreich - Sicherheitsmitarbeiter Benalla und  Macron
Image: picture alliance/AP Photo/C. Ena

A top security aide to French President Emmanuel Macron was sacked on Friday after it emerged he had beaten a protester during a demonstration in May, the president's office said Friday. 

The presidential Elysee Palace said it dismissed Benalla after "new evidence" had emerged. According to AFP news agency, the president's former aide is suspected of unlawfully receiving police surveillance footage in a bid to clear his name. Three police officers have reportedly been suspended on suspicion of providing Benalla with the footage.

Earlier on Friday, Alexandre Benalla was detained and questioned by authorities on allegations of assault and impersonating a police officer. 

A source close to the inquiry told AFP that Macron's cabinet chief, Patrick Strzoda, had been also questioned by investigators on Thursday.

The damaging scandal hit the Macron government on Wednesday after Le Monde newspaper published a video of Benalla dragging away one protester before moments later hitting another during May Day protests in Paris. 

Benalla is seen in the video wearing a police helmet and surrounded by riot police. 

Taha Bouhafs, a student activist, posted the original video on Twitter. 

Benalla is not a policeman but had been given permission to "observe police operations" during a day-off for the May 1 public holiday, the Elysee Palace said Thursday, as it sought to respond to a growing public backlash. 

Frankreich Macrons Sicherheitshelfer Alexandre Benalla
Alexandre Benalla had worked on security during Macron's presidential campaign before moving to Elysee PalaceImage: picture-alliance/dpa/MAXPPP

Benalla had been suspended from his position and given a desk job for two weeks when the incident first came to light in May.

However, he retained his office in the presidential palace, where he was responsible for organizing security for Macron's trips.

Just days ago, Benalla was seen helping to organize security for France's World Cup team celebrations.

The president's office sought to dispel the notion that harsher action would be taken against Benalla only because the three-month-old incident had become public.

The Elysee Palace told AFP that "new elements" had emerged in the case, in particular that Benalla may have illegally received police surveillance footage in an attempt to prove his innocence.  

Three officers have also been suspended from the force for providing the footage, a source told AFP. 

Allegations of double standards

The perceived lenient initial punishment of the aide opened up Macron's office to criticism that there had been a cover-up and preferential treatment. 

Read more: Opinion: Labor Day should prompt workers to create a new union-led counterbalance

Richard Ferrand, a senior MP from Macron's party and key figure in his campaign team, said "it was not a close aide, it's someone who was responsible for security of the president during the election campaign and then joined the Elysee."

But opposition MPs were quick to suggest there had been a cover up and raised questions over why the incident had not been taken to the police when it was revealed in May. A parliamentary inquiry is set to investigate the incident itself, the lenient initial punishment and the failure by authorities to promptly report Benalla to the judiciary.

Read more: May traditions in Germany: Colorfully decorated trees, scary witches — and protests

"This video is shocking. Today, we have the feeling that in Macron's entourage, one is above the law. It is obvious that Macron has to speak up about this," Laurent Wauquiez, president of conservative opposition party Les Republicains told Europe 1 radio.

Socialist Party leader Olivier Faure said there was "a double standard" in how Benalla had been treated compared to any ordinary French citizen.

Alexis Corbiere, an MP for the hard-left France Unbowed party, said Benalla "deserves to be punished with a prison sentence, at least a suspended sentence and with very heavy sanctions."

dm,cw/tj (AFP, AP, dpa, Reuters)

Each evening at 1830 UTC, DW's editors send out a selection of the day's hard news and quality feature journalism. You can sign up to receive it directly here.