1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

Disadvantaged in Germany

Johanna Schmeller / bkSeptember 12, 2013

Foreigners have worse chances on the German job market than Germans, the Cologne Institute for Economic Research has found. Worst affected are immigrants from Muslim countries.

Frauen und Kinder gehen am Donnerstag (28.05.2009) in Köln an der Agentur für Arbeit vorbei. Die Zahl der Arbeitslosen in Nordrhein- Westfalen ist im Mai leicht gesunken. Landesweit waren gut 812 000 Erwerbslose gemeldet, etwa 9500 weniger als im April, wie die Regionaldirektion NRW der Bundesagentur für Arbeit berichtete. Im Vergleich zum Mai 2008 gibt es aber etwa 45 000 Arbeitslose mehr. Foto: Oliver Berg dpa/lnw +++(c) dpa - Bildfunk+++
Image: picture-alliance/dpa

No German passport, no job? Using data from the German Federal Employment Agency, the Cologne Institute for Economic Research (IW) has now for the first time compared the chances of Germans and foreigners in the country's labor market. The result is clear: people who move to Germany have significantly worse prospects of landing a job.

People on part-time employment, public officials, and the self-employed were not taken into account by the new statistics - which meant that the owners of foreign restaurants, for instance, were also not counted. Only foreigners with residence permits were included, so refugees and asylum seekers were also left out of the figures.

Young unemployed man in Germany +++(c) dpa - Bildfunk+++
Unemployment is at seven percent in GermanyImage: picture-alliance/dpa

But despite these limitations, there remains an "unambiguous overall picture," said Holger Schäfer, labor market consultant at IW, "Fundamentally, foreigners have a much higher unemployment rate than Germans." In fact, it is about double: while the unemployment rate in Germany in June was 7 percent, for people without a German passport it was around 14 percent.

Muslim immigrants most affected

Immigrants to Germany from predominantly Muslim countries had the highest unemployment rates - particularly those from Lebanon, Iraq, Afghanistan, and Iran. "That is surely also because people don't come to Germany for professional reasons, but as refugees, and so find it more difficult to get a professional foothold," said Schäfer.

Unemployment rates among non-Germans

In absolute terms, most of the unemployed people of foreign origin also belong to the largest immigrant groups in Germany: 140,000 of the 460,000 Turks, for instance. A Turk living in Germany is two or three times more likely to be unemployed than a German.

Professional immigrants are well-integrated

On the other hand, immigrants from other Western nations barely show up in the stats. French, British, or American people apparently have the same chances as Germans. "Eastern Europeans also hold their own well: Poles, for instance, are only barely more often unemployed than Germans," said Schäfer. "And Romanians, who are often accused of coming to Germany to take advantage of the welfare system, are actually slightly less likely to be unemployed than Germans."

BERLIN - SEPTEMBER 05: Young women training to become seamstresses work at sewing machines shortly before the arrival of German Chancellor Angela Merkel at the BildungsWerk Kreuzberg, a vocational training school in the immigrant-heavy district of Kreuzberg, on September 5, 2008 in Berlin, Germany. Merkel is visiting schools across Germany in order to get a better unserstanding of the state of Germany's education system. (Photo by Sean Gallup/Getty Images)
Job qualifications need to be targeted at the immigrant community, says SchäferImage: Getty Images

Qualification is key

Schäfer said a "deficit in qualification" was largely responsible for the higher rate of unemployment. Foreigners often either have no or only very limited educational qualifications, with a quarter of them having no job training qualifications at all, compared to 8 percent among Germans. "The employment agencies have to do more to target young people from abroad," said Schäfer.