1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites
A man shouts slogans in support of the impeachment of suspended Romanian President Traian Basescu, depicted on banner in a prison cell, during a rally by anti-Basescu parties in Bucharest, Romania, Thursday May 17 2007. Some thousands gathered demanding a vote for the impeachment of Basescu in the upcoming May 19 referendum. The Romanian Parliament suspended Basescu, on April 19, for 30 days to organize a national referendum on his impeachment for alleged serious constitutional abuses.(AP Photo/Vadim Ghirda)
Image: AP

Romanian troubles

Keno Verseck / db
August 13, 2012

Romania is beset by a political power struggle with endless squabbling in a highly-charged political standoff. The stakes are high and the Balkan country's constitutional court has turned to the EU for help.


For weeks, Prime Minister Victor Ponta's government has tried to have suspended President Traian Basescu removed from office, violating laws and rulings by the Constitutional Court as a means to an end. The government's efforts have been blasted as a "revolution of thieves" by Romania's Hotnews website. Forgery of the country's eligible voters and election fraud have meanwhile been added to the list of grievances.

On August 10, prosecutors at Romania's Supreme Court made public transcripts of intercepted phone calls made by ministers and senior officials.

The calls showed Ponta's government was planning to falsify electoral lists on a large scale: tens-of-thousands of people were to be declared dead and expatriate Romanians were to be taken off the lists. The Romanian judiciary has launched a probe into the alleged manipulation of voter rolls.

Insufficient voter turnout

The doctored data was aimed at retroactively declaring valid a controversial referendum on July 29 to impeach Basescu. The 50-percent turnout necessary for an impeachment of the president was not reached: about 46 percent of the electorate cast ballots, with an overwhelming majority - 80 percent - of those voters in favor of removing the center-right president from power.

Source News Feed: EMEA Picture Service ,Germany Picture Service Romania's suspended President Traian Basescu addresses media at his campaign headquarters in Bucharest July 27, 2012. Basescu urged Romanians to boycott a July 29 referendum to remove him from office on Friday, the last day of a campaign that has divided the country and raised European Union concerns over respect for rule of law. The ruling leftist Social Liberal Union (USL) of Prime Minister Victor Ponta suspended Basescu earlier this month, saying the rightist president overstepped his powers. Basescu, in turn, accused the USL of trying to stage a coup and take control of independent institutions. REUTERS/Bogdan Cristel (ROMANIA - Tags: POLITICS)/ eingest. sc
President Basescu survived the impeachment referendumImage: reuters

The power struggle between the governing majority and the head of state has maneuvered Romania into its worst political crisis in two decades. According to the Bucharest daily Adevarul, the country is suffering from "political collapse." Former Justice Minister and current member of the EU parliament, Monica Macovei, describes Ponta's cabinet as "a law-breaking government that has marginalized Romania in the EU."

Just days after the referendum, Romania was in an uproar. The Constitutional Court is due to rule on the validity of the vote on unseating Basescu. Chief Constitutional Court judge, Augustin Zegrean, has meanwhile turned to the European Commission and the Council of Europe for help to protect its independence from political pressure asserted by Ponta's government. In an official letter to the EU bodies, Zegrean revealed there have been threats to the court's judges.

Beleaguered rule of law

European Commission President Jose Barroso and European Rights and Justice Commissioner Viviane Reding expressed support for the Court, saying in a letter the Commission was "committed to ensuring respect for the rule of law and the independence of the judiciary in Romania."

Foreign Minister Titus Corlatean has accused Zegrean of harming the country's reputation with his letter of complaint.

The uproar over the Constitutional Court, according to Peter Eckstein- Kovacs, a well-known human rights lawyer and political leader for the country's ethnic Hungarian minority, illustrates "that the rule of law in Romania is not really developed" and that "an attack on the few areas of the state that are still working" is underway.

Powerbrokers "not interested in EU values"

Socialist Prime Minister Victor Ponta has since, on several occasions, called for accepting defeat in the struggle with President Basescu. However, this standpoint is apparently not shared by the hardliners in his party.

Victor Ponta.jpg Von: Marketing ROMPRES [mailto:marketing@rompres.ro] Gesendet: Montag, 16. April 2007 12:48 An: diana.hodali@dw-world.de Betreff: pictures ROMPRES Wichtigkeit: Hoch Dear Diana Hodali, Thank you for your interest. The prices for each of them is of... Please enter our site www.rompres.ro and search the asked pictures: - ROMPRES FOTO (left)
Victor Ponta appears to have lost the power struggle - for the time beingImage: Rompres

Observers believe that Ponta has little real power in the Social Democratic Party he leads and that regional powerbrokers, who also control their local economies, have the most influence over his political fate. To make matters worse, the premier is facing criticism for allegedly plagiarizing portions of his doctoral thesis.

Laura Stefan, a Romanian lawyer and member of an EU oversight panel that regularly reviews Romania's progress toward the rule of law, is convinced that "no rules are being obeyed" and that "a large part of the political elite is not interested in EU values and would rather see Romania outside the EU."

"Everything we arduously built over the last two decades toward a civil society is now being destroyed in just a few days," Stefan said.

Skip next section Explore more
Skip next section DW's Top Story

DW's Top Story

A Ukrainian tank stuck in the mud

Ukraine counteroffensive: When will the mud season end?

Skip next section More stories from DW
Go to homepage