1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

Tough Fight Ahead

Trinity HartmanJanuary 14, 2008

With national elections looming, Spain's politicians have been sidestepping controversial issues such as gay marriage and abortion. Yet recent mass demonstrations and strikes show the issues aren't going away.

Street protest in Madrid with Spanish flags
Spaniards take to the streetsImage: AP

Prime Minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero has developed an image as a firebrand ready to shake up Spain's conservative Catholic establishment. His Socialist party passed Europe's most progressive same-sex marriage legislation, introduced fast-track divorce and chipped away at religious education in public schools.

But ahead of a fiercely-contested national election scheduled for March 9, Zapatero is trying to polish his credentials as a moderate. His nemesis, conservative Popular Party (PP) leader Mariano Rajoy, is doing the same.

Both parties are desperate to win over undecided voters. The Socialist party is leading by only a few percentage points in the polls and it's likely that the race will remain close to the end. The PP won in 1996 and 2000, largely by winning over moderates. But the Socialists attracted enough swing votes to win the last elections in 2004.

Going for the political middle

People lie covered in tomatoes as part of an annual festival
How these Spaniards will vote is anyone's guessImage: AP

Spain's swing voters are set to decide the elections again this year, said political scientist Pablo Onate of the University of Valencia. Spanish voters have a history of punishing parties that are not seen as being close enough to the center, Onate said.

"This is another case in which that is going to happen," he said. "Both parties are trying to be center-orientated."

Spain's parliament was dissolved on Jan. 14. A 15-day electioneering period starts Feb. 22, but Spanish politicians are in full pre-election swing, trying to define the most important issues for the voters. Political parties will definitely spend a lot of time talking about the economy and terrorism, but social issues are where the parties most differ and will therefore play an important role in the political debate, Onate said.

The Spanish population, while still conservative compared with Northern Europe, is much more liberal today than it was 10 or 15 years ago, Onate said. Yet the Socialists still rely on support from voters ambivalent about issues like abortion. And the PP needs the votes of young people more accepting of gay rights.

Downplaying the abortion issue

Spanish Prime Minister Zapatero looks down
Zapatero is reaching for the centerImage: AP

Reforming Spain's restrictive abortion laws seemed like a social issue Zapatero would embrace. Indeed, in December he promised to make the issue part of this year's electoral campaign. He reversed his line a short time later, saying only that he wants to reassess current abortion laws.

The PP would also rather not talk about abortion, said Onate. The party did nothing to restrict abortion laws during its time in office.

Yet both parties might find it hard to ignore the issue. On Jan. 8 abortion clinics launched a five-day strike to protest what they feel is lack of government support and harassment from officials and pro-life activists. The issue came into the spotlight after allegations surfaced that illegal abortions were being done at clinics in Barcelona.

Spain's Catholics assert themselves

Three Spanish bishops take part in a rally against gay marriage
Catholic leaders have spoken out against gay marriage

One hot button issue for conservative Catholic voters is Spain's legalization of gay marriage in 2005. The Spanish Roman Catholic Church jumped into the fray, warning that the country faced a grave moral danger. The Socialists pushed through the legislation anyway.

That issue continues to incense voters. More than 150,000 people demonstrated in Madrid on Dec. 30 for a "Christian Family Day" rally organized by Catholic bishops. The event was billed as a defense of traditional family values. But it took on a political edge as the bishops denounced politics which they say threaten the family.

The government is "shaking the foundations of the family with its unique and unjust laws," Cardinal Antonio Canizares of Toledo said at the Madrid rally.

Cardinal Agustin Garcia-Gasco of Valencia criticized "the culture of radical secularism is a deception which only leads to abortions and fast-track divorces."

The Catholic Church should be making its opinion known on issues such as family, said Jose Carlos Martin de la Hoz, a prominent Catholic historian and theologian. Spain's Catholics shouldn't keep quiet in the face of secularization which they see as destroying the fundaments of family, he said.

The recent demonstration was an example of Catholics taking part in the dialogue about social issues, Martin de la Hoz added.

Gay marriage likely to motivate voters

Opposition leader Mariano Rajoy
Rajoy doesn't want to be seen as a reactionaryImage: AP

Rajoy, who has repeatedly denounced the same-sex marriage laws, is not turning out to be the strong ally conservatives had hoped for. In an effort to make himself attractive to moderates and to show his political independence from the Catholic Church, Rajoy promised last week that the PP won't repeal Socialist legislation on abortion, same-sex marriage and fast-track divorce.

This infuriated many conservative groups like "Hazte Oir" (Make Yourself Heard). Hazte Oir's president, Ignacio Arsuaga, said he sees same-sex marriage as a key issue in the upcoming election. The PP has said it would like to see the term "marriage" dropped in favor of a civil union, but has promised to let a court make the final decision. Rajoy also promised to appoint a family minister.

While that's a start, it's not good enough, said Arsuaga. Hazte Oir launched a campaign to put pressure on the PP to take a stronger stand on the issue. They're also planning demonstrations and advertising campaigns.

Same-sex marriage supporters wave rainbow flag
Same-sex marriage has very vocal supporters -- and opponentsImage: AP

Antonio Poveda, president of the State Federation of Lesbians, Gays and Transsexuals (FELGT), a group essential in organizing massive gay pride demonstrations in favor of same-sex marriage, said his group wasn't planning any street protests. But they would be engaging in public information campaigns ahead of the election, he said.

Poveda said Spain has become one of Europe's most progressive countries in same-sex issues, with same-sex marriage continuing to have 60 percent approval.

He thinks the recent attacks on gay marriage by conservative Catholics will backfire because "people are sick of having that type of doctrine imposed on them."