1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

Germany Hits Out At US Sanctioning of Secret Prisons

DW staff (sp)
September 9, 2006

German Chancellor Merkel, who has worked to boost ties with the US since taking office, rebuked Washington on the use of secret prisons by the CIA -- admitted for the first time by US President Bush.

Bush's admission has angered the German governmentImage: AP

"The existence of such prisons is not compatible with my understanding of the rule of law. Even in the fight against terrorism... the ends do not justify the means," Merkel said in Berlin on Saturday. "Instead we must find answers to how we can combat terrorists effectively without calling our fundamental principles and beliefs in question," she said.

Since media reports first revealed the CIA operation last November, Bush and other members of his administration have refused to publicly discuss the program. At the end of last year, US Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice visited Europe and defended Washington's treatment of its detainees in the war on terrorism, but did not address the issue of whether the CIA had operated secret prisons.

George W. Bush - Rede
President Bush's admission has angered manyImage: AP

This week however, US President George W Bush admitted for the first time that the CIA was running secret prisons where high-level al Qaeda figures captured since the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks were held and interrogated. He did not name their locations.

"Highly questionable"

The revelation has also added weight to a report by the Council of Europe in Strasbourg, the continent's main human rights watchdog and independent from the EU, which said that several European states had helped the US carry out "extraordinary rendition" flights, the US practice of transporting detainees to other states for interrogation.

Bush's public admission has prompted renewed calls by European lawmakers that their governments divulge the locations of the secret CIA prisons.

Germany's Interior Minister Wolfgang Schäuble also condemned the detentions.

"I've never seen a reason for interning terror suspects -- like in Guantanamo -- outside the jurisdiction of American courts. It's highly questionable," Schäuble told regional paper Passauer Neue Presse, adding that he had no information that the CIA had operated secret prisons in Germany.

Guantanamo Häftlinge beim Gebet
Bush is already under fire for the Guantanamo Bay prison campImage: AP

"Our American friends are also well advised to protect our freedom and legal system in such a way as to ensure that the fundamental principles of the legal system are not abandoned. When it comes to a ban on torture there can be no leeway," Schäuble said.

The German government's human rights commissioner, Günter Nooke said it was unacceptable that President Bush seemed to want to justify the "special interrogations" in the prisons.

"I want to know where the prisons are and who knew about them," Nooke said.

Reinhard Bütikofer, head of the opposition Green Party accused Bush of "leading the world along for years."

Bush und Merkel stecken die Köpfe zusammen
Merkel enjoys close ties with BushImage: AP

Despite her criticism, Merkel however said she welcomed the fact that Bush had raised the issue of the prisons himself.

Merkel has enjoyed warm relations with the American president since succeeding Gerhard Schröder last year.