1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites
Anti-reform demonstrators in MainzImage: AP

Few Protest as Welfare Cuts Take Hold

DW staff/AFP (ncy)
January 3, 2005

A small number of protestors hit the streets in 10 German cities Monday, a day after a sweeping reform of welfare payments aimed to cut long-term unemployment went into effect.


Unfazed by the protests, Labor and Economics Minister Wolfgang Clement (photo below) told the weekly Bild am Sonntag he was confident "that the most comprehensive reform of the job market in the history of the Federal Republic of Germany will eventually be a success."

Wirtschaftsminister Wolfgang Clement zu Emissionshandel
Wolfgang ClementImage: AP

"I will be responsible for its success or failure," he added.

The controversial package of labor market reforms known as Hartz IV will have a wide-reaching impact on the lives of 4.5 million people out of work in what is still Europe's economic powerhouse. It is impossible to tell for the moment exactly how many unemployed will lose money under the new system or who will benefit from the changes.

But those expected to feel the changes hardest are the long-term jobless and the 2.7 million people who the Federal Labor Agency says have used up their benefits and now receive only minimum welfare payments. The agency says less than 10 percent will lose their welfare payments altogether, a figure the unions reject. They put the figure at 27 percent and say 48 percent will have their income reduced.

To calculate the new benefits, the Federal Labor Agency analyzes peoples' estate, their expenditure and their needs, which is already sparking controversy.

Generous system

The government argues that overhauling Germany's generous social welfare system -- once envied throughout the world -- will persuade people who have been out of work for more than a year to accept a job, no matter how low paid. But support groups for the unemployed have criticized a move they say will make the poor poorer.

Other observers have called for recognition that even after the reforms are introduced, the German welfare state will be relatively generous to the unemployed. For example, the point at which the value of an unemployed person's residential property is taken into consideration is €200,000 ($270,000) and only 9 percent of homes in western Germany and three percent in eastern Germany are valued higher.

Demonstranten protestieren am Montag, 3. Januar 2005, vor dem Arbeitsamt in Duisburg gegen die Einfuehrung der Hartz IV-Gesetze.(AP Photo/Michael Sohn)
Few protestors gathered outside a labor office in the western German town of Duisburg on TuesdayImage: AP
Monday's protests came in the wake of demonstrations last year which were held for weeks on Mondays, similar to rallies which brought down former East Germany's communist regime in 1989. Anti-Hartz IV Monday protests eventually fizzled out but widespread unease with the reform translated into severe electoral blows for Chancellor Gerhard Schröder's Social Democratic Party.

Skip next section Explore more
Skip next section DW's Top Story

DW's Top Story

Hands holding a rainbow flag

Russian law bans LGBTQ 'propaganda'

Skip next section More stories from DW
Go to homepage