Possible export of nuclear waste draws criticism | Germany | News and in-depth reporting from Berlin and beyond | DW | 05.01.2013

Visit the new DW website

Take a look at the beta version of dw.com. We're not done yet! Your opinion can help us make it better.

  1. Inhalt
  2. Navigation
  3. Weitere Inhalte
  4. Metanavigation
  5. Suche
  6. Choose from 30 Languages


Possible export of nuclear waste draws criticism

Germany has decided to phase out nuclear power, but what about the leftover nuclear waste? A new law would allow Germany and other EU countries to export radioactive material.

Yellow barrels of nuclear waste at a temporary storage site in Morsleben. Foto: Jens Wolf dpa pixel Schlagworte Atommüllfässer , .Umwelt , Müllfässer , .Bergbau , .Atommüll , .Atom , .Altlasten

Barrels of nuclear waste

The search in Germany for a permanent storage facility for nuclear waste has been a long slog and has so far led nowhere. Late last year, due to ongoing protests by the anti-nuclear lobby, Environment Minister Peter Altmaier announced an end to suitability studies on an old salt mine in Gorleben, Lower Saxony, which for a long time was viewed as a possible long-term site for storing nuclear waste.

Altmaier and SPD chairman Sigmar Gabriel (v.l.), Bundesumweltminister Peter Altmaier (CDU) und der Praesident des Bundesamtes fuer Strahlenschutz (BfS), Wolfram Koenig, gehen am Freitag (01.06.12) waehrend eines Besuchs des Atomlagers Asse II in Remlingen durch einen Stollen. Foto: Julian Stratenschulte/Pool/dapd.

German Environment Minister Altmaier (centre) is responsible for the draft law

Now, a new draft law has emerged in the midst of the waste site debate. Changes to the existing law would allow the possible export of spent nuclear fuel to storage facilities abroad. The law is required because of EU guidelines from 2011 that must be enshrined in national law by all member states by August 2013.

EU guideline

The draft, which Deutsche Welle has seen, allows the "permanent storage" of nuclear waste abroad when "at the time of delivery there is a valid accord between the Federal Republic of Germany and the third-party country." In other words, German nuclear waste may be stored outside of Germany, provided certain conditions are met: for example, that the storage facility in which the German waste is to be stored was already operational prior to the export of the waste.

In response to criticism from environmental groups, the German government has denied that plans are afoot to send German nuclear waste abroad. However, Berlin emphasized that Germany is obliged under European law to insert the criticized paragraph into existing German law.

"German nuclear waste is, as a matter of principle, to be stored in Germany," said a spokesman for the Environment Ministry in Berlin. Chancellor Merkel's spokesman, Steffen Seibert, added that German responsibility for German nuclear waste was "unchanged and 100 percent."

ARCHIV: Faesser mit leicht radioaktivem Atommuell werden in Remlingen (Kreis Wolfenbuettel) im ehemaligen Bergwerk und heutigen Atommuell-Endlager in eine Einlagerungskammer gekippt (Foto undatiert). Am Mittwoch (12.12.12) findet in Berlin eine Pressekonferenz zur fraktionsuebergreifend erarbeiteten Lex Asse statt. Der im frueheren Salzbergwerk Asse lagernde Atommuell soll schneller aus der maroden Schachtanlage geholt werden. In den vom frueheren Betreiber verschlossenen Kammern des vom Einstuerzen und Volllaufen bedrohten Bergwerks lagern rund 126.000 Faesser mit schwach und mittelradioaktivem Muell. Mit diesem Gesetz wollen wir eine parallele Vorgehensweise erreichen, dass wir also nicht mehr warten muessen, bis die Rueckholung bestaetigt ist, hatte Bundesumweltminister Peter Altmaier (CDU) bei seinem Besuch in der Asse-Region am 23. November angekuendigt. Unter anderem sollten durch die sogenannte Lex Asse kuenftig verfahrensrechtliche Regelungen gelockert werden. (zu dapd-Text) Foto: Helmholtz Zentrum Muenchen/dapd.

The Asse salt mine is Germany's only permanent nuclear waste storage facility.

Haggling over language

Environmental groups, however, argue that Minister Altmaier has gone overboard with his draft. Tobias Münchmeyer, deputy director of political affairs for Greenpeace in Berlin, told DW that Altmaier had gone "far beyond what came out of Brussels and had created a basis for shunting nuclear waste off to Russia, for example."

In particular, there is one passage of the EU guidelines missing in the German draft. In the guidelines it says that "radioactive waste is to be stored permanently in the member state in which it is generated." Exceptions can only be made under certain circumstances. Münchmeyer argues that the German draft makes the export of waste an equally possible option.

National export ban is controversial

Barrels with radioactive waste at Gorleben. Photo: GNS Gesellschaft für Nuklear-Service mbH, Rechtefrei für DW

Gorleben is currently only a temporary storage site

Whether the German draft could actually ban the export abroad of German nuclear waste entirely is questionable. Sabine Schlacke, Professor for Public Law at the University of Bremen, believes this cannot be done.

"I think that the option for sending waste abroad by a member state must be allowed because the guideline stipulates this," she says. Otherwise, nuclear plant operators could possibly demand that waste be stored in their own country. Schlacke maintains that the German Environment Ministry has stuck to the EU guideline in its draft law.

Critics remain wary, however, and argue that a mere promise by the government not to export nuclear waste is not enough. Radioactive waste remains dangerous for thousands of years.

DW recommends