1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

German Doctors Go on Strike

DW staff / AFP (jdk)August 2, 2005

German doctors have begun nationwide protests against long working hours and pay cuts. On Monday, 1,400 doctors took to the streets in two states to kick off the weeklong action.

"Overtime is unhealthy"Image: AP

The pain threshold for young doctors in German hospitals has been reached. On Monday in the states of Baden-Württemberg and Hesse, over 1,400 physicians hung up their stethoscopes on the office door and hit the streets to protest poor working conditions.

The banners the doctors carried sent a clear signal to hospitals, particularly state-run facilities, around the country: "Better Pay for Better Work" and "England Pays Twice as Much."

On the first day of weeklong protests that will culminate on Friday in Berlin with a "national day of protest," leaders from the Marburger Bund doctors' union are looking to raise the awareness of the plight of German doctors compared to their peers abroad.

Overtime without compensation

ÄRZTESTREIK Krankenhausärzte der Uniklinik Frankfurt demonstrieren am Montag, 1. Aug. 2005, mit Transparenten und Luftballons vor dem Universitätsklinikum in Frankfurt am Main
Physicians of Frankfurt's University hospital protest against their working conditions. The banner reads "Money away, doctor away."Image: AP

In a country where many laborers receive extra compensation for working overtime, at night or under dangerous conditions, the doctors seem to have a point. The Marburger Bund said that some 146,000 hospital doctors perform 50 million hours of overtime each year, most of them without extra compensation, and that Germany trailed far behind comparable nations in physicians' salaries.

The chairman of the union, Frank Ulrich Montgomery, said the budget cuts at university clinics were equal to "state-supported robbery of wages." The doctors say they have been forced to bear the brunt of budget cutbacks at public health institutions, seeing their Christmas and vacation bonuses slashed while working hours increase.

"As long as French, British and American colleagues earn two or three times as much, nothing will stop the flight of doctors abroad and the shortage of physicians," said Montgomery.

Particularly disturbing to the union was the grave discrepancy between young assistant doctors and head physicians.

27-year-olds fresh out of college begin with a take-home pay of around 2,500 euros ($3,000) per month. Their superiors, frequently with managerial duties, earn up to 12 times that amount.

The system is at fault

Ärzte bei der Arbeit im Operationssaal
Overtime is frequently left unpaid in German hospitalsImage: Bilderbox

While the younger physicians have taken to the streets demanding fairer work schedules and more pay, others say it is the system that doctors created for themselves that is at fault.

"The union leaders can't come up with a better idea than to demand more pay," criticized Kurt Lauterbach. The health care economist points out that the two-tier health care system, where little money can be earned with public health plan patients and a lot with private patients, leads to young doctors receiving poor wages.

"This system is unjust and must be revamped," Lauterbach declared.

This must also be done in the interest of German patients. Young doctors are taking their abilities to other countries where they know the rewards are greater. According to the latest figures from the doctors' union, around 6,000 positions remain unfilled at German hospitals. The same number are registered abroad.

One area where all parties concerned agree, is the amount of time that German physicians spend mired in medical bureaucratic procedures. According to Christian Democratic social affairs expert Andreas Strom, this costs them up to 30 percent of their work time.