Hamburg′s unfinished concert hall becomes a political failure | Arts | DW | 12.04.2010
  1. Inhalt
  2. Navigation
  3. Weitere Inhalte
  4. Metanavigation
  5. Suche
  6. Choose from 30 Languages

Arts

Hamburg's unfinished concert hall becomes a political failure

If it had been clear from the beginning just how expensive Hamburg's Elbphilharmonic concert hall would become, no one would have agreed to build it. The project is turning into an embarrassment to the city.

The construction site of the Elbphilharmonic in Hamburg near the harbor at night time

The Elbphilharmonie is currently expected to be completed in 2013

The new building of the Elbphilharmonie rises high above the old dock storage above the Hamburg harbor. The first pieces of the facade have already been attached and foretell how the bold design by Swiss architects Herzog and de Meuron will look one day.

The Elbphilharmonie is set to become a symbol with as much international power as the opera in Sydney or the Guggenheim museum in Bilbao. Yet the building's original construction costs have climbed from 77 million euros ($104 million) to 323.5 million euros. Now, the residents of Hamburg no longer see the construction site as a beacon of prestige but rather as a gigantic black hole for their tax money.

The opening of the concert hall had originally been slated for September 2010, but has since been postponed to 2013. The city may sue the construction company Hochtief for refusing to adhere to a binding construction deadline.

Computer simulation of the future Elbphilharmonie

This computer simulation shows the Elbphilharmonie as it will look after completion

Unexplained difficulties with unique design

"We would like to understand this a bit better," said Heribert Leutner, the director of the association in charge of Hamburg city construction.

The only thing that is known, he said, is that the large concert hall - meant to be a one-of-a-kind steel structure - has become problematic for the construction company. But what exactly these problems might be remains unclear.

"So far, Hochtief has not given us any explanations as to why they are having such difficulties with the steel construction," Leutner said.

Does the communication between the builder and the construction company have to go through court? What's at stake is liability - and a lot of money, said Leutner. If Hochtief does not adhere to construction deadlines, the company will face heavy penalties.

A computer simulation of the largest hall inside the new Elbphilharmonie

The Elbphilharmonie boasts a unique design

Social Democrats plan investigation

The Elbphilharmonie's large building site at the Hamburg harbor may cause another unpleasant surprise for the city and its taxpayers. With building costs expected to explode, Hamburg's SPD opposition party wants to set up an inquiry.

Christoph Lieben-Seutter, general manager of both the yet-to-be-built Elbphilharmonie and the Laeiszhalle, a century-old concert house in Hamburg, was the first to publically announce the delay of the opening. Hamburg's cultural officials chose to avoid the matter.

Negative press made it increasingly difficult to find financial sponsors for the construction project. Admittedly, reliable deadlines would make it easier to rent the new concert house, but "a project like this never ceases to be unique and sensational," said Lieben-Seutter.

It could have been cheaper

Lieben-Seutter is currently organizing a series entitled "Elbphilharmonie Concerts," which take place in the Laeizhalle and other venues. He conceded that a building as elaborate as the new Elbphilharmonie may not even be necessary in order to put on high-caliber musical performances like the ones he organizes.

A picture of Christoph Lieben-Seutter, general manager of the Elbphilharmonie and the Laeiszhalle

Christoph Lieben-Seutter was the first to admit the construction needs more time

"The Elbphilharmonie has two identities," he said, "It is a concert hall and also an architectural landmark. But a good concert hall can be a lot less expensive and a lot more modest."

That makes it all the more disappointing that Hamburg's Elbphilharmonie has become a symbol of failed politics. In his work as director of the two concert houses, Lieben-Seutter is active in many projects that support children from socially disadvantaged city neighborhoods. It is those groups who may feel the loss of the money that has been thrown into the Elbphilharmonie.

Author: Dirk Schneider (ad)
Editor: Kate Bowen

DW recommends

Advertisement