German court rules pre-election ministry raids were ′inappropriate′ | News | DW | 10.02.2022

Visit the new DW website

Take a look at the beta version of We're not done yet! Your opinion can help us make it better.

  1. Inhalt
  2. Navigation
  3. Weitere Inhalte
  4. Metanavigation
  5. Suche
  6. Choose from 30 Languages


German court rules pre-election ministry raids were 'inappropriate'

The raids took place just weeks before last year's German elections and targeted top candidate Olaf Scholz among others. Now, a court has invalidated search warrants granted to public prosecutors.

A police van passes in front of Germany's Federal Finance Ministry

The raids made headlines just days before Germans voted, causing some to ask if Olaf Scholz was being intentionally smeared

A district court in Osnabrück in Lower Saxony on Thursday officially invalidated search warrants previously granted to public prosecutors last September.

At the time, prosecutors had insisted that Christine Lambrecht — then justice minister, now defense minister — and her Social Democratic colleague Olaf Scholz — then finance minister, now chancellor — were involved in quashing investigations into money laundering by a special unit of Germany's customs agency.

Osnabrück prosecutors claimed that the Finance Intelligence Unit (FIU) at customs — which falls under the aegis of the Federal Finance Ministry — and employees at the Justice and Finance Ministries were intentionally obstructing justice. When the Justice Ministry refused to hand over communications with the Finance Ministry to prosecutors, these sought search warrants.

On Thursday, the district court said that the warrants should not have been granted and that the raids should not have been carried out.

Court: 'No indication of misconduct at the Justice Ministry'

The court called the searches "inappropriate" and "unnecessary," saying there was no urgency to the issue nor was there reason to fear the destruction of evidence.

Prosecutors told the court they had feared "loss of evidence" may occur as a result of departmental turnover after the election.

Nevertheless, the court noted that a prior investigation had already secured documents prosecutors were seeking, and noted that there had been no "indication of misconduct" at the Justice Ministry.

Moreover, the court said prosecutors' actions were disproportionate to their suspicions and that by insisting on pressing ahead regardless, they had significantly "damaged the reputation of the Federal Republic of Germany and its institutions."

Lambrecht's successor at the Justice Ministry, Marco Buschmann, said he welcomed the court's "clear decision," adding, "One can trust the Justice Ministry and the men and women who work there — that is the most important message."

The raids made headlines at the time, putting front-running chancellor candidate Scholz under intense pressure. Scholz, who cruised to election victory, even appeared before investigators days before the vote. 

"I used the opportunity to once again explain that the last three years have probably been the best years for beefing up our capabilities in regards to fighting money laundering and terrorist financing," Scholz told reporters after testifying in the Bundestag, the German parliament.

Watch video 03:07

Investigators raid two German ministries: DW's Jared Reed reports

js/fb (AFP, dpa)