German authorities have warned of the risks posed by nanotechnology when used in food, clothing, cosmetics and other products. The promising potential of the technology comes with a risk for health and environment.
Germany's Federal Environment Agency has advised consumers against using such products until their long-term effects on people's health has been carefully studied.
Nanoscience deals with matter on an ultra-small scale. A nano particle is 40,000 smaller than the width of the average human hair.
Nanotechnology has often been hailed as a technology of the future. But it's already used in a wide array of products. Paints with nano particles allows graffiti to be washed off more easily. Tooth fillings with nano particles are less likely to fall out.. Nanotechnology is also used in a variety of food products, such as sugar where the particles make the sugar crystals sprinkle better.
Nanotechnology can make sugar crystals sprinkle better
Professor Dieter Stuermer from the Bonn-based Institute for Science and Ethics says people should be especially aware of the danger that nano particles can damage lungs and cause inflammation. In particular, he criticizes nanotechnology companies for not taking enough account of the possible negative side-effects of their products.
No studies of long term risks
"In my opinion, this is the wrong strategy altogether," Stuermer told Deutsche Welle. "There's no sense in working solely towards a desired result and neglecting any side-effects that may show up in the process. We need more research on the risks involved. And most of all, there has to be an open public debate about it."
This open debate however, has not taken place, critics warn. Not only because there are no long-term studies available on the impact of nano particles on human health. But also because consumers don't even know what products include nanotechnology due to a lack of any kind of labeling system.
The Federal Environment Agency has called for a clear legal framework to provide a safe way to use the new technology. All products using nanotechnology should be listed, the agency suggests.
The technology of the future?
Yet there are others that warn against demonizing the new products merely because of unproven side-effects. Urban Wiesing from Tuebingen University in southern Germany agrees that more research must be done on possible health hazards. So far, only about three percent of publicly allocated research funds in Germany go towards risk assessment schemes. But Wiesing doesn't see any insurmountable problems.
Nanotechnology can make planes lighter and more fuel efficient
"I strongly believe that many of the risks associated with nanotechnology have at least in part been encountered in other technologies as well," he told Deutsche Welle. "That's why I'm confident that regulations can be found to ensure that these risks can be minimized in the interests of the users of nano products."
The Federal Environment Agency in its report admits that the new technology does not only pose risks but also offers vital chances for the environment. For instance, plastic with nanotechnology can help to reduce the weight of cars and planes and thereby help to save fuel. Also in the research on energy friendly light bulbs nanotechnology was of crucial help.
The German ministry for education and research is convinced that nanotechnology will be a major factor in boosting the German economy as the country fights its way out of the current recession. It believes that sales of nano products globally could be worth three trillion US dollars over the next six years.
Author: Hardy Graupner/ai
Editor: Michael Lawton